How much could YOU save?
Request free quotes; find out now.
  • Someone may have
    just saved up to
    $910/yr
    on car insurance.
    Actual quote delivered: 2 hours ago
    Quote Range: $1,340-$2,250/yr
    Age: 25 Sex: Female
    State: California Tickets: 0
    Number of Quotes: 5
    Vehicle: 2008 NISSAN ALTIMA 2.5 S
  • Someone may have
    just saved up to
    $1,390/yr
    on car insurance.
    Actual quote delivered: 2 hours ago
    Quote Range: $2,880-$4,270/yr
    Age: 20 Sex: Female
    State: Texas Tickets: 0
    Number of Quotes: 5
    Vehicle: 2007 CHEVROLET COBALT LS
  • Someone may have
    just saved up to
    $1,408/yr
    on car insurance.
    Actual quote delivered: 2 hours ago
    Quote Range: $2,594-$4,002/yr
    Age: 26 Sex: Female
    State: Connecticut Tickets: 1
    Number of Quotes: 3
    Vehicle: 2005 TOYOTA COROLLA CE/LE/S
  • Someone may have
    just saved up to
    $1,456/yr
    on car insurance.
    Actual quote delivered: 1 hours ago
    Quote Range: $1,068-$2,524/yr
    Age: 20 Sex: Female
    State: Virginia Tickets: 2
    Number of Quotes: 2
    Vehicle: 2004 VOLKSWAGEN JETTA GL
  • Someone may have
    just saved up to
    $1,016/yr
    on car insurance.
    Actual quote delivered: 1 hours ago
    Quote Range: $968-$1,984/yr
    Age: 51 Sex: Male
    State: California Tickets: 1
    Number of Quotes: 5
    Vehicle: 2004 TOYOTA COROLLA CE/LE
We Scour. You Save.
We search the web to find the very best deals and money-saving tips. Then, we send them right to you.
Get insurance now:
Car Insurance Resources:
Get Free Quotes Now
Save With CarInsurance.com!
Car Insurance Learning Center  Learning Center  Auto Insurance Questions & Answers   Questions & Answers  Professional Answers   Auto Insurance Answers

My son was involved in a 3 car accident. Car #1 stopped abruptly in the street. Car #2 hit car #1 in the rear. Car #3 (my sons car) hit car #2. The insurance company is saying Car #3 is principally at fault because he failed to maintain a safe distance. Why wouldn't car #1 be at fault? He stopped for no apparent reason.

State negligence laws differ but most all states require a driver to not follow too closely and to maintain a safe distance so that a driver has time to stop without hitting the car in front of them.

Insurance companies investigate an accident and determine fault based on driver statements, police reports, state laws, the state definition of negligence, etc.

From the account you gave of the accident it would appear that your son's car (vehicle #3) would at least be responsible for car #2's damages. If car #2 was only hit into car #1 after your son's car hit them then depending upon state laws he may be responsible for both vehicles' damages.

Though the first car may have stopped for no apparent reason the cars behind that driver should have left enough stopping distance to stop without striking the vehicle in front of them, taking reasonable care as drivers.

If the first car had stopped due to a child or animal running out into the street the cars behind would have needed the same stopping distance. Or if the person's car had broken down and stopped running the cars behind should have maintained a safe distance so they would be able to stop. Thus the reason for the first car stopping may not be as important to the insurance company involved as the reason that the other cars were unable to stop without colliding.

Free Auto Insurance Quotes





[Let CarInsurance.com help you find affordable auto insurance now.]

To find out how more about how the insurance company determined fault contact the insurance adjuster assigned to the claim. For information on your state's negligence laws try contacting your local Department of Motor Vehicles.

Share this article with:

Related Questions
Car Insurance Related Can rust and previous damage be deducted from ACV settlement amount?
Car Insurance Related Does comprehensive cover stolen tools?
Car Insurance Related Can I be paid lost wages without being injured?
Car Insurance Related Is rekeying my car covered if keys are stolen?
Car Insurance Related Is my parked car covered if I have limited tort?
Rate, add comments, or add help about your situation and this question.
Help us improve the largest car insurance website!

poor 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

 excellent
Tell us why you rated this car insurance question and answer this way. You can add any helpful insurance comments to this page:
Visitor Comments
No visitors have commented on this answer.
Question Details
This car insurance answer was last updated 2:09 PM Mar-29.
This Insurance Claims question was asked 07:57 PM March-25-2007.
Rick requested this car insurance help from CarInsurance.com experts.
Rated 0 out of 10 based on 0 votes.
Insurance Claims Category
Print Car Insurance Answers Print this car insurance question and answer
Email Car Insurance Answers Email this auto insurance answer
Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided are for information purposes. They are not intended to substitute informed professional advice. These responses should not be interpreted as a recommendation to buy or sell any insurance product, or to provide financial or legal advice. Please refer to your insurance policy for specific coverage and exclusion information. Please read our Terms of Service.
©2012 QuinStreet Insurance Agency, Inc. - Online Insurance Marketplace™
CarInsurance.com Feedback Survey