CarInsurance.com Buy Insurance Online
> ZIP code:  Quote & Compare
Prefer to talk to an agent? Call 1-800-964-4849
CarInsurance.com Navigation

Get Free Quotes Now

Zip Code:
Save With CarInsurance.com!
Car Insurance Learning Center  Learning Center  Auto Insurance Questions & Answers   Questions & Answers  Professional Answers   Professional Answer

Car Insurance Question  My windshield was cracked by a golf ball while I was driving on county road that was near the golf course. Is the golf course liable for the damage since I do not know who hit my car? The golf course did not have any protective netting along the road where my car was hit.

We have researched this topic and it seems to depend upon state laws and even on previous case law whether a golfer or golf course can be held liable for an errant golf ball that leaves the property and strikes a vehicle, pedestrian, house, etc.

We have read that in many cases the golf course is not considered responsible for the actions of its golfers. Golf courses may have a policy where they will try to help find the golfer responsible but will bear no responsibility for errant golf shots that leave the course.

While state laws do differ in general it appears that many jurisdictions do not hold the golf courses responsible and in some cases the golfer is not held responsible either. This issue has been taken to court many times and the result in many jurisdictions is that there is not negligence on the golfer's fault since he or she does not know where the ball is going.

There is a theory of assumed liability in law which operates to protect such businesses as a golf course, an airport or other public access venues when you either partake of the services or know of the existence and continue to be in proximity. One lawyer we spoke to stated that you drove past the golf course with knowledge (under the legal definition) that a ball had the opportunity to travel outside the boundaries and strike your vehicle, therefore you have an unmitigated level of liability.

This information is from one lawyer in one state so your state laws could differ however in general even if there was negligence on the part of the golf course; you would have to prove that the owner's and employees exercised less than ordinary care in causing your damages in many cases to obtain a judgment against the golf course.

There are some lawyers that will take up a case against a golf course stating that it would be negligent of the course owner not to protect against such a foreseeable occurrence as a golf ball leaving the grounds. So you may find a lawyer that would take the case due to the fact no netting or fencing was placed around the area you drove by. If there were trees though that the course uses as a natural protective barrier your case may not be seen to have merit by a judge.

For example, a New York court decided on a case in 1991 (Rinaldo v. McGovern) by recognizing that merely because a golf ball does not travel in the intended direction does not establish a viable negligence claim.

In this court case an errant shot broke the windshield of a car traveling on a road adjacent to the golf course. The New York court applied traditional tort liability requirements that there must exist a recognizable risk and a basis for concluding that the harm following from the consummation of the risk was reasonably preventable. The court concluded that the game of golf is such that the risk of a miss /hit golf ball is not a fully preventable occurrence. In other words, the court said the risk was foreseeable, but not preventable.

Court cases we have read demonstrate that a golf course and golfer's duties depends on the particular facts of each case and state laws. If you did not inform the golf course of the golf ball striking your car at the time of the incident then it would not appear possible for them to try to track down the responsible golfer. So you may to now want to see if the golf course owners will voluntarily take responsibility for the damages. You may speak with the managers at the club house of the golf course to see if they have insurance that would cover the repair or replacement of your windshield.

If the course does not take responsibility then you can make a claim against your own comprehensive coverage to get your windshield repaired. In most states you will need to pay your deductible however in some states such as Florida, state law requires the deductible to be waived for windshields. Another option is to seek legal counsel to determine if in your state you can go against the golf course for the damages the golf ball did to your car.

Share this on: Digg This StumbleUpon Add to Facebook Add to Del.icio.us Furl It Seed Newsvine
reddit this! Save to Ma.gnolia Save to Blinklist Technorati This Submit to Netscape Windows Live Favorites Add Google Bookmark
Related Questions
Car Insurance RelatedWhat vehicles are exempt from the mandatory insurance requirement?
Car Insurance RelatedThis question is regarding a golf cart. My golf ball was on green, my friend who was playing with me has a golf cart and he asked me to drive the cart towards the green. I accidentally placed my foot...
Car Insurance RelatedA golf ball shattered the back windshield of my car while parked in the golf course parking lot. Who is responsible and why?
Car Insurance RelatedWhere can I purchase insurance for just my golf cart?
Car Insurance RelatedI was at a Florida golf course and hit a ball that hit the windshield of a city police car as it was driving down the road parallel to the fairway. Am I required by Florida law to pay for repairs or s...
Car Insurance RelatedWhere can I get golf car insurance only?
Car Insurance RelatedI live in New York and have a broken windshield that is non-accident related. Do I have to pay my insurance deductible to have my windshield replaced?
Car Insurance RelatedCan you be given a ticket in NY for having a cracked windshield if the drivers vision is not impaired or distorted? My windshield is cracked on the passenger side but in no way impairs or distorts my...
Car Insurance RelatedWhile we were driving, a flying rock hit our car by someone mowing their yard. Who would be at fault on this - their homeowners insurance or our car insurance?
Tell us what you think about this answer.
What did you think of this question and answer?

poor 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

 excellent
Tell us why you rated this car insurance question and answer this way:
Visitor Comments
No visitors have commented on this answer.
Question Details
This car insurance question was asked on 9/1/2007
This auto insurance answer was last updated on 9/5/2007
William Y requested this car insurance solution.
Rated 0 out of 10 based on 0 votes.
Claims
Print Car Insurance Answers Print this car insurance question and answer
Email Car Insurance Answers Email this auto insurance answer
Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided are for information purposes. They are not intended to substitute informed professional advice. These responses should not be interpreted as a recommendation to buy or sell any insurance product, or to provide financial or legal advice. Please refer to your insurance policy for specific coverage and exclusion information. Please read our Terms Of Use.
©2008 CarInsurance.com, Inc. - Online Insurance Marketplace™
safe and secure auto insurance   better business bureau car insurance   Tested, Safe, and Secure Car Insurance