How much could YOU save?
Request free quotes; find out now.
  • Someone may have
    just saved up to
    $1,057/yr
    on car insurance.
    Actual quote delivered: 3 hours ago
    Quote Range: $1,306-$2,362/yr
    Age: 22 Sex: Male
    State: Florida Tickets: 1
    Number of Quotes: 3
    Vehicle: 1999 FORD MUSTANG
  • Someone may have
    just saved up to
    $994/yr
    on car insurance.
    Actual quote delivered: 3 hours ago
    Quote Range: $1,560-$2,554/yr
    Age: 24 Sex: Female
    State: California Tickets: 1
    Number of Quotes: 4
    Vehicle: 2007 TOYOTA COROLLA CE/LE/S
  • Someone may have
    just saved up to
    $1,294/yr
    on car insurance.
    Actual quote delivered: 2 hours ago
    Quote Range: $1,558-$2,852/yr
    Age: 56 Sex: Male
    State: California Tickets: 1
    Number of Quotes: 5
    Vehicle: 2006 JEEP GRAND CHEROKEE LIMITED
  • Someone may have
    just saved up to
    $994/yr
    on car insurance.
    Actual quote delivered: 2 hours ago
    Quote Range: $1,526-$2,520/yr
    Age: 70 Sex: Male
    State: Wisconsin Tickets: 1
    Number of Quotes: 2
    Vehicle: 2008 TOYOTA PRIUS
  • Someone may have
    just saved up to
    $1,474/yr
    on car insurance.
    Actual quote delivered: 2 hours ago
    Quote Range: $1,630-$3,104/yr
    Age: 28 Sex: Male
    State: Texas Tickets: 1
    Number of Quotes: 5
    Vehicle: 2011 DODGE CHARGER R/T
We Scour. You Save.
We search the web to find the very best deals and money-saving tips. Then, we send them right to you.
Get insurance now:
Car Insurance Resources:
Get Free Quotes Now
Save With CarInsurance.com!
Car Insurance Learning Center  Learning Center  Auto Insurance Questions & Answers   Questions & Answers  Professional Answers   Auto Insurance Answers

When a car is totaled can you make the insurance company fix the car instead of taking the cash?

No, you cannot force an insurance company to fix a car if they have determined it to be a total loss. State laws and insurance company guidelines vary however if an insurance carrier has decided that it is uneconomical to repair the vehicle than it is very unlikely you can get them to change their decision.

If you want to keep your vehicle and have it repaired than you can speak to the insurance company about buying back the vehicle and paying them salvage value for it.

If you have made a claim through your own insurance provider and they have determined your vehicle is to be totaled they will settle with you usually by paying actual cash value (ACV) for the vehicle less deductible and take the car so they can sell it for salvage value.

If state laws allow than your insurance company may pay you actual cash value less deductible and less salvage value so that you keep the car. You then would be free to repair the vehicle with your payment but generally the payment would not be sufficient to cover all repairs and that is the reason the insurer totaled out the vehicle. The insurance company however would not be obligated to pay any more since they "made you whole" by paying out the value of the vehicle to you already.

[Let CarInsurance.com help you find affordable auto insurance now.]

Free Auto Insurance Quotes





So sometimes the insurance company may want to total your car, but you would prefer to have it repaired instead. In this case if state laws and the insurer allows, you can keep your car if you are willing to subtract its salvage value from the insurance settlement.

You can contact the claims adjuster working your claim if you have questions about buying back your vehicle after it has been declared a total loss as part of the settlement process. Keep in mind though that it may be difficult to find insurance for a car with a branded (salvage or rebuilt), which your vehicle would have after being totaled out by the insurance company. So you may want to call around to make sure you can obtain car insurance for the vehicle before deciding to buy it back.

Share this article with:

Related Questions
Car Insurance Related How is my car determined to be a "total loss"?
Car Insurance Related I bought a new car. Four days later I was hit by a UPS truck while it was parked at work. It is a hybrid with alot of complicated electronics, and batteries. Can I demand that their insurance replace my car with a new unwrecked car?
Car Insurance Related What happens when you are hit and the other person's insurance company says that "it will cost too much to fix your car"? Then they decide to total your car. Who puts the value on your car and do you get to keep your car?
Car Insurance Related Will insurance still pay if I choose to fix my own car?
Rate, add comments, or add help about your situation and this question.
Help us improve the largest car insurance website!

poor 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

 excellent
Tell us why you rated this car insurance question and answer this way. You can add any helpful insurance comments to this page:
Visitor Comments
No visitors have commented on this answer.
Question Details
This car insurance answer was last updated 10:42 PM Oct-29.
This Save Money question was asked 10:13 AM October-22-2008.
Ernest L. requested this car insurance help from CarInsurance.com experts.
Rated 0 out of 10 based on 0 votes.
Save Money Category
Print Car Insurance Answers Print this car insurance question and answer
Email Car Insurance Answers Email this auto insurance answer
Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided are for information purposes. They are not intended to substitute informed professional advice. These responses should not be interpreted as a recommendation to buy or sell any insurance product, or to provide financial or legal advice. Please refer to your insurance policy for specific coverage and exclusion information. Please read our Terms of Service.
©2012 QuinStreet Insurance Agency, Inc. - Online Insurance Marketplace™
CarInsurance.com Feedback Survey