CarInsurance.com Car Insurance Rate Quotes
> ZIP code:  Quote & Compare
Prefer to talk to an agent? Call 1-800-964-4849
CarInsurance.com Navigation

Get Free Quotes Now

Zip Code:
Save With CarInsurance.com!
Car Insurance Learning Center  Learning Center  Auto Insurance Questions & Answers   Questions & Answers  Professional Answers   Professional Answer

Car Insurance Question  I am being held 10% liable for a collision that was caused by a driver passing a stop sign without stopping. I had no controls on my traveling road. The insurance company said that I had a last clear chance to avoid the collision. What is comparative Negligence and "last clear chance"?

States typically have either a comparative or contributory negligence laws. Comparative negligence laws mean that parties involved in an accident may share the cost of damages from an accident in proportion to the share of their negligence. A motorist determined to be 50% or less at fault may recover their damages minus the percent cause by their own negligence. If more than 50% there would be no recovery for losses from the other party usually.

Contributory negligence is much stricter and means that if you are even slightly at fault in a collision you are not entitled to any recovery against the other driver even if they were mostly at fault for the incident.

Ultimately for claim purposes the insurance companies involved will investigate the accident claim to determine fault. This is done by the insurance adjusters whose job it is to determine the extent to which you are covered and the degree of fault of each driver. Sometimes an adjuster will split up fault differently than the police or determine fault to be placed on a different person then what the police report states.

An adjuster's investigation and determination of the claim usually takes into account both drivers' recollection of the accident, any witness statements and the damage of both vehicles. Insurance adjusters will also be guided by state laws. Since you were found 10% at fault in a comparative negligence state you should ask the claims adjuster what parameters were used to determine each party’s degree of responsibility.

Comparative negligence (also called comparative fault in some areas) usually comes into play when it is contended by a driver or the insurance company involved that two or more parties failed to perform at the standard of the "ordinary reasonable person". Since the insurance company is bringing up "last clear chance" this may mean that they believe from their finding that although you did not have a stop sign or were required to yield that you did have time to either swerve or stop so that the accident did not occur.

With the last clear chance it typically means that the insurance company believes that the driver had the time and means to avoid the accident. The driver negligently failed to use that available time and means to avoid the accident. For example if you were approaching the intersection and though you did not have a stop sign saw that the other car was speeding and not going to stop in time than an insurer can say you had a last clear chance to stop and not allow the accident to occur.

For a couple of other examples of when reasonable care or last clear chance come into play, say your light turned green in an intersection and you proceed on though you see another driver is running the red light. An insurer may say you did not take reasonable care to ensure the intersection was clear before proceeding even though your light was green.

Or what if there is an accident with a person merging onto the freeway. The person entering the freeway is supposed to yield those already on the roadway however if the lane next the merge lane is open and the other driver failed to move over and make room than they may be found to have not taken a last clear chance to move over and avoid the accident from occurring.

Without knowing the specific details of the accident we cannot tell you why the insurance adjuster can to this conclusion about your situation however he should be able to explain to you how he found you to be 10 percent negligent and what last clear chance you had to avoid the collision.

Share this on: Digg This StumbleUpon Add to Facebook Add to Del.icio.us Furl It Seed Newsvine
reddit this! Save to Ma.gnolia Save to Blinklist Technorati This Submit to Propeller Windows Live Favorites Add Google Bookmark
Related Questions
Car Insurance RelatedI was involved in a accident where the other driver changed lanes into me. She was issued a ticket and told the police she did not know what happened. I called her insurance company to get the claim g...
Car Insurance RelatedMy wife was hit by a guy who ran a stop sign. She had no stop sign. His insurance company is agreeing to pay 90% of the claim. Saying she is 10% at fault. Is that proper? Also, I dont believe that the...
Car Insurance RelatedMy daughter was getting out of her friend's car that was parked. Another friend was pulling into the parking space beside them and hit the opening door. (The dad of the girl driving the car that hit t...
Car Insurance RelatedIf I back out of my driveway and hit a car that is parked on a one lane tree in front of my driveway, is it my fault? I have asked my neighbor to repeatedly park in his driveway or someone other than...
Car Insurance RelatedWhat are the comparative negligence laws if any in Missouri? For more back ground to determine who was at fault the story is as follows. I was driving out of a parking lot onto a street where parking...
Car Insurance RelatedI live in Queens, NY and am an uninsured driver. I was involved in an accident that was deemed 30% my "fault". I was driving a car that was a gift to me and is not registered in my name. Are...
Car Insurance RelatedI was recently in a fender bender in AR. The police were called, but when they came out they could not determine what driver was at fault. So he made us switch insurance information and write out a re...
Car Insurance RelatedWho is at fault if someone opens a car door as another car is pulling into the parking space next to them and hits it? The situation is I was pulling into the parking space but I stopped for a second...
Car Insurance RelatedI live in Ohio. I was parked in a no-parking zone, without blocking traffic, while I went to get something inside a building. A U-Haul truck made a sharp turn and hit my car. Am I at fault since it...
Car Insurance RelatedAuto turned left in front of my vehicle at an intersection. The light was green and the other vehicle did not have a turn arrow. I hit vehicle that turned into my path. The liability insurance comp...
Tell us what you think about this answer.
What did you think of this question and answer?

poor 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

 excellent
Tell us why you rated this car insurance question and answer this way:
Visitor Comments
No visitors have commented on this answer.
Question Details
This car insurance question was asked on 12/29/2008
This auto insurance answer was last updated on 1/5/2009
Isis K requested this car insurance solution.
Rated 0 out of 10 based on 0 votes.
Claims
Print Car Insurance Answers Print this car insurance question and answer
Email Car Insurance Answers Email this auto insurance answer
Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided are for information purposes. They are not intended to substitute informed professional advice. These responses should not be interpreted as a recommendation to buy or sell any insurance product, or to provide financial or legal advice. Please refer to your insurance policy for specific coverage and exclusion information. Please read our Terms Of Use.
©2009 CarInsurance.com, Inc. - Online Insurance Marketplace™
safe and secure auto insurance   better business bureau car insurance   Tested, Safe, and Secure Car Insurance