Call Us Toll Free: 1-855-430-7753

New York Car Insurance

New York drivers get off comparatively easy, with state car insurance rates that stack up well against the rest of the nation. But the five boroughs are another story. Staten Island is cheap only compared with Manhattan, and Manhattan looks good only compared with Brooklyn, where rates for our sample driver topped $4,000 a year. We've got every ZIP in New York mapped out below.

New York Car Insurance Requirements
Average Car Insurance Rates in New York
Car Insurance Companies in New York

New York car insurance requirements

New York state law requires the following minimum car insurance coverage:
Minimum bodily injury liability $25,000/$50,000
Minimum property damage liability $10,000
Personal injury protection $50,000 limit

New York Car Insurance Rates by ZIP Code & City

Top Cities
Priciest Neighborhoods
In New York
  • 11226: $3,877
  • 11221: $3,872
  • 11212: $3,872
  • 11207: $3,872
Cheapest Neighborhoods
In New York
  • 14870: $900
  • 14830: $900
  • 14901: $913
  • 14903: $913

New York Car Insurance Quotes

Get real, custom quotes
and buy a better policy in minutes!

What you need to know about car insurance in New York

Penny Gusner
Consumer Analyst

New York Car Insurance Laws

Minimum auto insurance coverage requirements for New York are $25,000 for bodily injury per person, $50,000 for bodily injury per accident and $10,000 for property damage.

The minimums may be fine if you don't have many assets or live in a rural area where accidents are less likely, but if you live in a metropolitan area, such as New York City, or have many assets to safeguard, bump your limits up to 100/300/50 or more.

Uninsured motorist bodily injury is also required as part of a New York auto insurance policy. New York also mandates motorists to carry at least $50,000 in personal injury protection (PIP), sometimes referred to as no-fault insurance.

No-fault doesn't mean that no one is found at fault for an accident, but instead that someone who is injured in an accident looks first to his or her own coverage. If PIP limits are exceeded, then the at-fault driver's liability coverage can kick in.

Basic no-fault: PIP coverage includes:

  • Reasonable and necessary medical and rehabilitation expenses
  • 80 percent of lost earnings (up to maximum of $2,000 per month for three years)
  • Up to $25 per day for replacement services (e.g. household help)
  • Death benefit of $2,000

    Exclusion to no-fault coverages: Most New York car insurance policies say that a person may be ineligible for PIP benefits if the individual was:

    • Driving while intoxicated or impaired by drugs and that contributed to the accident
    • Riding an all-terrain vehicle (ATV) or motorcycle as driver or passenger
    • Intentionally causing his or her own injuries
    • Injured while committing a felony
    • Injured while in a stolen vehicle
    • An owner of an uninsured vehicle

    Surcharges: If you cause a car accident, New York law says your insurer can raise your rates (known as a surcharge) only if you caused bodily injury or property damage that was more than $2,000. You can also be surcharged if you're convicted of certain traffic violations. As in any state, keeping your driving record clean will go a long way toward holding down your car insurance rates.

    Uninsured motorist penalties for New York: You may have to pay $150 to $1,500 in fines and could receive a sentence of 15 days in jail. You may also have your license and registration suspended and your car impounded.

    How long does an accident affect your insurance? An accident normally remains on a New York motor vehicle record (MVR) during the year that the accident occurred and for the following three years. The accident is then removed on January 1 of the forth year after the accident.

    No grace period: There is no grace period allowed in New York before you renew your insurance or obtain insurance on a new car. In fact, the law requires that you mail your insurance renewal forms at least 15 days before your cancellation date.

    Driver's license points: In New York, points stay on your record for 18 months. Points are counted from the date of your violation, not from the date of your conviction.

    Age restrictions: If you are a minor, insurance companies normally will require that a parent or guardian will need to sign on your insurance policy with you since it is a legal and binding document. The New York DMV allows only ages 16 and up to apply for a title and registration.

    Largest car insurance companies in New York by market share

    Rank Company / Group Premiums Written ($) Market Share (%)
    1 Berkshire Hathaway Insurance 3,216,565 28.95
    2 Allstate Insurance Group 1,724,838 15.52
    3 State Farm Group 1,384,293 12.46
    4 Progressive Insurance Group 765,285 6.89
    5 Liberty Mutual Insurance Companies 720,584 6.48
    6 Travelers Group 525,378 4.73
    7 Nationwide Group 322,307 2.90
    8 NYCM Insurance Group 291,320 2.62
    9 USAA Group 282,679 2.54
    10 Hartford Insurance Group 219,310 1.97
    Source: A.M. Best market share rankings are based on direct premiums written in 2013.