CarInsurance.com Insights
- Car color doesn’t directly affect insurance rates. Insurers generally don’t ask about or price based on your vehicle’s color.
- The red‑car myth is just that — a myth. Beliefs that red or flashy colors cost more to insure are not supported by how insurers set premiums.
- Real pricing factors include driving record, vehicle type and location. These factors have a documented influence on risk and premiums.
- Custom paint jobs can affect insurance needs. Unique or expensive aftermarket paint might require custom parts and equipment coverage because of higher repair costs.
- Visibility or theft concerns don’t drive pricing. While certain colors might be easier to spot or perceived as more theft‑prone, insurers do not use color itself in actuarial models.
Why car color doesn’t affect car insurance rates
Though many drivers worry about their car’s paint job impacting insurance costs — especially the idea that red cars cost more to insure — this is a persistent myth rather than an underwriting reality. Insurers do not use vehicle color as a pricing factor because it has no reliable statistical link to claim frequency or severity.
When you get a quote, your insurer pulls data tied to risk and expected costs, such as your driving record, age, ZIP code and the type of vehicle you drive — none of which include paint color.
How auto insurers actually price your policy
Insurance premiums are determined by actuarial data that reflects actual risk — not aesthetic choices.
Primary factors insurers consider
- Driving history: Tickets, accidents and claims history influence risk.
- Vehicle type and repair costs: Cars that are expensive to fix or are involved in more claims cost more to insure.
- Location and usage: Where you live and how much you drive affect theft and accident exposure.
- Coverage choices and limits: Higher limits and broader coverage categories result in higher premiums.
These factors are quantifiable and backed by statistical risk models, unlike vehicle color.
What is the origin of the “red car” myth?
The myth that red cars are more expensive to insure likely stems from associations with sports cars and performance vehicles, which do tend to have higher premiums — but because of speed, horsepower and repair costs, not the color of paint.
Another reason this belief persists is psychology and cultural perception: red is a bright, attention‑grabbing color, which drivers associate with speed and risk. However, insurance pricing algorithms ignore color entirely and focus on measurable risk factors.
Speak with a friendly agent and get your quote in minutes!
When paint‑related factors can affect insurance costs
While paint color itself doesn’t influence premiums, there are two scenarios where appearance‑related factors can matter:
Custom or after‑market paint jobs
If you add an expensive custom paint job or wrap, that modification increases your vehicle’s replacement cost. Insurers may require optional custom parts and equipment coverage to protect that investment, which can raise your premium.
Color as part of theft or claim reporting
Insurers may record your car’s color for identification or administrative purposes (e.g., in claims or police reports), but this does not enter their pricing models.
Practical tips for buyers concerned about insurance costs
- Choose a car based on safety ratings and repair costs. These have a proven impact on insurance costs.
- Maintain a clean driving record. No factor matters more to your premiums than your driving history.
- Disclose custom work. If you add non‑standard paint, notify your insurer and adjust coverage accordingly.
- Compare quotes. Since insurers’ pricing models vary, compare multiple carriers to get the best rate for your specific vehicle and profile.
Conclusion
The color of your car — whether red, black, white or any other hue — does not directly affect your insurance premiums. Insurers base rates on measurable risk factors like your driving behavior, vehicle type and location.
The longest‑standing belief that certain colors cost more to insure has no basis in underwriting practices. The one exception is when aesthetic choices — like custom paint jobs — increase a car’s value, which then affects optional coverage costs.
Frequently Asked Questions: Car color and insurance rates
Does the color of my car affect insurance rates?
No, insurance companies do not use your car’s color to calculate premiums. Rates are based on factors like your driving record, location, vehicle make/model and coverage level.
Why do people say red cars cost more to insure?
This is a persistent myth. Red cars are often associated with sports cars, which may have higher premiums — but it’s the car’s performance and repair cost, not the color, that drives rates.
Do insurers even know my car’s color?
Yes, insurers may record your vehicle’s color for claims or identification purposes, but they do not factor it into your rate calculations.
Can custom paint jobs raise my insurance premium?
Yes. If you install aftermarket or custom paint that increases your vehicle’s value, you may need special coverage like custom parts and equipment insurance, which can raise your premium.
What actually affects my car insurance rates?
Key rating factors include your driving history, location, credit (in most states), vehicle safety and repair costs, claims history, age and coverage choices.
Still have a question? Ask our experts
Get advice from an experienced insurance professional. Our experts will help you navigate your insurance questions with clarity and confidence.
Browse all FAQs
