If you’ve ever heard the term surety bond and wondered how it fits into car insurance, you’re not alone. It may sound technical, but the idea is actually quite simple. Instead of buying a regular auto insurance policy, you can, in some cases, use a surety bond to show the state that you’ll pay for any damage you cause while driving.
This option is for individuals who are considered high-risk, have difficulty obtaining standard insurance or want to meet the legal minimum requirements instead of getting an auto policy.
What is a surety bond for auto insurance, and how does it work?
A car insurance surety bond is essentially a financial guarantee to the state that you’ll take responsibility for any damage you cause while driving. Instead of purchasing a traditional auto insurance policy, you get a bond from a surety company.
In this arrangement, there are three parties involved: you (the principal), the state or DMV (the obligee, which requires the bond) and the surety company, which guarantees your obligation.
Here’s how it works
You purchase a bond from a licensed surety company for a specific dollar amount required by your state. If you cause an accident, valid claims can be paid from the bond up to that amount.
You pay the surety back. The surety isn’t taking the risk the way an insurer does; it’s guaranteeing your obligation. Anything it pays out, it will seek to recover from you.
Car insurance surety bonds are most often used in states that allow them as an alternative to proof of financial responsibility, especially for drivers who have difficulty obtaining a standard policy or have serious violations on their driving records.
While a bond can meet state requirements, it doesn’t shield you from financial loss the way regular insurance does. You’re still responsible for every dollar paid out, so a surety bond is more about proving you can pay, rather than paying on your behalf.
When and why you might need a surety bond instead of car insurance
You might need a surety bond instead of a standard auto policy in the following situations:
- Your state allows you to get a surety bond: Some states let you file a surety bond as an alternative form of financial responsibility instead of buying a standard liability policy. In those states, you might choose a bond simply because the law gives you that option.
- You’ve been classified as a high-risk driver: If you have multiple at-fault accidents, serious violations like DUI/DWI or a history of driving without insurance, your insurer might flag you as a high-risk driver. In such cases, a surety bond can be an option when standard policies are too expensive or difficult to get.
- You own multiple vehicles and prefer to self-insure: Some individuals with multiple cars and significant assets may use a surety bond as part of a self-insurance strategy. Instead of paying premiums to an insurer, they use the bond to demonstrate to the state that they can cover claims themselves.
- You only want to meet the legal minimum requirement: A surety bond can satisfy your state’s minimum financial responsibility requirement, but it does not provide extra protection like collision, comprehensive or other optional coverages. You might choose a bond if your goal is solely to comply with the law, rather than to purchase broader coverage.
If your goal is to protect your assets from a big accident bill, a standard liability policy, often with higher limits and even an umbrella policy, is usually smarter. Choose a surety bond when the priority is meeting state requirements and you’re prepared financially and mentally to reimburse any payouts.
Surety bond vs. car insurance
A surety bond and car insurance aren’t the same thing. Car insurance is protection for you: you pay premiums, and if there’s a covered accident, your insurer pays for the damage up to the policy limits.
With a surety bond, if the bond company pays a claim on your behalf, you must pay them back, so the financial risk ultimately comes back to you. Bonds can sometimes be used to meet financial responsibility requirements, but they don’t replace the broader protection a standard auto insurance policy provides.
| Feature | Surety bond | Car insurance |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Guarantee you’ll pay others for damages | Protect you financially if an accident or loss occurs |
| Parties involved | Three: Principal, obligee, surety | Two: You and the insurance company |
| Who is protected? | Public/state (obligee) | You and others |
| Do you repay claims? | Yes. You must repay the surety for what it pays | No. Insurer pays covered claims; you pay the deductible |
| Covers damage to your own car | No | Yes, if you add collision/comprehensive |
| Covers injuries to others | Yes, up to the bond amount, but you repay the surety | Yes, under liability coverage |
| Upfront cost | Often lower than full insurance | Varies by driver risk; can be higher for high-risk drivers |
| Risk to you | Higher – you’re on the hook for all payouts | Lower – insurer bears most of the financial risk |
Speak with a friendly agent and get your quote in minutes!
Where can you get a car insurance surety bond?
Most large property and casualty insurance companies have surety departments. Additionally, there are companies for which surety bonds comprise the majority of their business.
Surety bonds are issued through surety bond producers, also known as agents and brokers, who operate in the surety industry. Surety bond producers typically work in agencies that specialize in surety bonds or in insurance agencies that deal in insurance policies and surety bonds.
Pros and cons of using a surety bond
Below are the pros and cons of using a surety bond as an alternative to car insurance:
Pros
- A surety bond is more affordable than paying for a complete auto insurance policy, but it doesn’t protect your vehicle.
- It helps you meet financial responsibility laws if your state allows bonds instead of traditional insurance.
- This can be an option for high-risk drivers who are having difficulty purchasing car insurance or are facing very high premiums.
- It allows you to get back on the road legally after certain violations, license issues, or lapses in coverage.
Cons
- You’re still financially responsible for any claims. If the bond company pays someone, you have to pay the bond company back.
- It doesn’t really protect you the way car insurance does; it mainly protects the other party and the state.
- Typically, it doesn’t cover damage to your own car, injuries, or additional expenses, such as towing, rental cars or roadside assistance.
Key takeaways on surety bonds
Surety bonds guarantee the performance or financial obligations of others. A simple definition is that a surety bond is a written agreement that typically provides for monetary compensation in the event the principal fails to perform the promised acts.
If you have trouble finding someone to issue you a surety bond, contact your state’s insurance regulatory body for consumer help.
Still have a question? Ask our experts
Get advice from an experienced insurance professional. Our experts will help you navigate your insurance questions with clarity and confidence.
Browse all FAQs
