Learn everything you need to know to buy the best car insurance policy in Indianapolis for your particular situation. You’ll see which carriers are rated as the best car insurance companies for customer satisfaction and the average car insurance rates for your neighborhood.

Discover how much you can save from knowing how to make intelligent choices about coverage. And find out how rates for Indianapolis drivers are affected by tickets, accidents and adding teen drivers.

Key Highlights
  • The average car insurance cost in Indianapolis, IN for a full coverage policy is $1,366 a year, according to CarInsurance.com research.
  • GEICO has the cheapest full coverage car insurance quotes in Indianapolis among all the carriers analyzed.
  • By comparing price quotes from different carriers, you can save an average of $1,729 per year on a full coverage policy in Indianapolis.
  • In Indiana, comprehensive insurance costs an average of $195 and collision coverage is $656 per year, based on CarInsurance.com rate analysis.

Who has the best car insurance in Indianapolis, IN?

Deciding who has the best car insurance to suit your needs depends on what is most important to you. For some, it may be price, while others value customer service the most. Still, others may be looking for the convenience of mobile apps, or a company that offers the most car insurance discounts.

Below we list car insurance companies in Indianapolis, and who they are the best at serving, based on CarInsurance.com’s customer satisfaction survey of current policyholders and rate data analysis.

Best forCompany
ClaimsUSAA
Value/PriceUSAA
Customer ServiceUSAA
Websites/AppsAmerican Family
RecommendUSAA
Low Annual MileageState Farm Mutual Auto
Good StudentNationwide Mutual
BundleAllstate P&C
Paid in FullAllstate P&C

Cheap car insurance in Indianapolis, Indiana

Find the cheapest car insurance rates in Indianapolis, based on our rate analysis for three different coverage levels. The driver profile is for age 30, with good credit and a clean driving record. You can see how major insurers rank for price in the chart below.

CompanyLiability Only – State Minimum BI/PDLiability Only – 50/100/50 BI/PDFull Coverage – 100/300/100 BI/PD – 500 Comp/Coll
GEICO Advantage Ins Co$213$265$765
American Family Ins Co$263$344$1,061
Auto-Owners Ins Co$310$389$1,298
State Farm Mutl Automobile Ins$324$400$1,143
Progressive Paloverde Ins Co$378$446$1,627
Standard Fire Ins Co$392$464$1,099
Depositors Ins Co$518$567$1,207
Farmers New Century Ins Co$611$776$1,692
Allstate P&C Ins Co$612$686$2,086
Metropolitan P&C Ins Co$840$980$2,476

Car insurance coverage – how much car insurance do I need in Indianapolis?

Below we’ll explain what coverage you need to drive legally, which is your state-required minimum liability limits, and what types of car insurance you may need to be truly protected.

Minimum car insurance requirements in Indianapolis

Indiana car insurance laws require only that you insure yourself against bodily injury and property damage liability, so it’s your choice whether to add coverage for yourself, your passengers, and your vehicle.

If you have a new car, getting comprehensive insurance and collision coverage makes sense. In Indiana, comprehensive costs $195 and collision costs $656, on an average per year, according to a rate data analysis done by CarInsurance.com.

These optional coverages come with a deductible. That’s the amount you pay before your insurance company pays. Typical deductibles are $1,000, $500 and $250 – you choose which one you want. The higher the deductible is, the lower your rate will be.

The best car insurance coverage usually isn’t the cheapest. You may be used if you’re in an accident and your insurance doesn’t cover all the damages. That means your home or savings could be in jeopardy.

To protect your assets, you should buy liability insurance in the following amounts:

  • $1,00,000 to pay for others’ medical bills
  • $3,00,000 to pay for injuries to others in an accident you cause
  • $1,00,000 to pay for damage to others’ property

You should also consider buying these optional coverages:

  • Comprehensive, which replaces stolen cars and covers damage to your car from floods, fire, hail and vandalism.
  • Collision, which pays for damage to your car from accidents.

Average car insurance rates in Indianapolis

According to our rate analysis, the average rate for Indianapolis drivers for a year of minimum coverage is $424. If you increase your coverage to 50/100/50, you would pay just about $5.92 more monthly, or $71 more a year.

You can get full coverage (100/300/100) by paying $78.50 more a month, or an additional $942 a year more than minimum-level coverage.

Indianapolis average for:

  • Minimum coverage: $424
  • 50/100/50: $495
  • 100/300/100: $1,366

Compare car insurance quotes in Indianapolis – how to save on insurance

You can save an average of $1,729 annually on a full coverage policy in Indianapolis by comparing car insurance quotes, according to CarInsurance.com’s rate analysis. While savings will depend on your particular circumstances, there is a significant benefit to shopping your policy.

Indianapolis car insurance FAQs

How much does insurance go up after a speeding ticket in Indianapolis?

A speeding ticket in Indianapolis will hike your car insurance rates by an average of 52%, or about $991 yearly. CarInsurance.com’s rate analysis shows how much more drivers in Indianapolis can expect to pay, on average, for speeding and other common violations.

Minor traffic violations, such as speeding, typically stay on your record for about three years, and you can expect to see the rate increase upon your policy renewal date. More severe infractions like DUI typically stay on your record much longer.

How much does insurance go up for tickets in Indianapolis?

Indianapolis drivers can expect to see a hike in their rates in the range of 54% for minor moving violations such as tailgating or blowing through a stop sign, 86% for more severe infractions such as DUI.

Below you’ll see how much rates increase, on average, for ordinary traffic violations.

Remember, though, that because insurance companies assess risk differently, you can still save by comparison shopping. One carrier may ding you a lot for a citation, while another may spike your rate by much less.

ViolationAverage rateRate after violation$ Increase% Increase
2 speeding tickets 11 mph or over$1,917$3,086$1,16961%
Careless driving$1,917$3,121$1,20463%
Distracted driving ticket$1,917$2,608$69136%
Driving without a license or permit$1,917$2,909$99252%
Driving without insurance$1,917$2,475$55829%
DUI/DWI first offense$1,917$3,358$1,44175%
DUI/DWI second offense$1,917$5,192$3,275171%
Failure to stop$1,917$2,579$66235%
Failure to yield$1,917$2,579$66235%
Following too closely$1,917$2,579$66235%
Improper turn$1,917$2,581$66435%
Improper/illegal pass$1,917$2,610$69336%
Operating a vehicle in a race (highway racing)$1,917$3,479$1,56281%
Reckless driving$1,917$3,597$1,68088%
Seatbelt infraction$1,917$2,409$49226%
Talking on cellphone ticket$1,917$2,533$61632%
Texting ticket$1,917$2,555$63833%

How much does it cost to add a teen driver to your insurance?

In Indianapolis, adding a 16-year-old daughter to your policy will hike your rates by $1,690 annually or 124%, and it’s more for boys. Insuring your 16-year-old son will increase your yearly rate by $1,886 or 138% according to CarInsurance.com rate data.

According to CDC research, teen drivers are inexperienced and involved in more accidents than older drivers. Insurance companies categorize them as high-risk drivers, so they cost more to insure.

If you’re insuring a teen driver of any age, you can get expert tips, rate data by age and details in this parents’ guide to insuring a teen driver.

How much is SR-22 insurance in Indianapolis?

CarInsurance.com data show that for drivers in Indianapolis, your rate will go up by an average of $1,195 or 62%. If you’re convicted of a serious offense, such as DUI or reckless driving, you may be required to have your insurance company file an SR-22 form on your behalf.

An SR-22 is a car insurance company’s guarantee to the state that you are carrying the legally mandated coverage. If you are required to have an SR-22 filed, your car insurance rates will increase.

 — Ashlee Tilford contributed to this story  

author image
Contributing Writer

Shivani Gite is a personal finance and insurance writer with a degree in journalism and mass communication. She is passionate about making insurance topics easy to understand for people and helping them make better financial decisions. When not writing, you can find her reading a book or watching anime.