Dealing with a car accident can be confusing and frustrating, especially when your car is totaled. There is a loss of control with your personal vehicle being taken away from you. But there are many options available.

For instance, if you have collision coverage, your insurer will pay you the cash value of the car. You also can repair the vehicle, sell it or take out the parts and sell them.

There are pros and cons with each option, which we’ll outline below. But note that with this guide we’re assuming you owned the car when it was declared a total loss. If you were financing the car when it was totaled, navigate over to total loss on a financed car.

How does the insurance company decide if the car is a total loss?

Each state has a total loss threshold.

For example, if your state’s threshold is 70%, that means that if the damage equals 70% or more of the car’s value, then the insurer will consider the car a total loss. Check out our list of total loss thresholds by state.

Your insurer may decide to total a car before the damage reaches that threshold, especially if they believe more damage will be found during the teardown/repair process. But once the estimate goes over the state’s threshold, it is required to be declared a total loss.

What to do with a totaled car : Following are the 6 options

  1. Take the money
  2. Keep the car and fix it
  3. Keep the car and don’t fix it
  4. Keep the car and sell it
  5. Part it out
  6. Donate it to a nonprofit

1. Take the money

This is the standard route when your car is totaled. The car insurance company is essentially buying your damaged car from you. They will calculate the car’s actual cash value and offer to send a check with that amount. They will also take the wrecked vehicle and auction it for salvage.

If you are going through your own collision coverage, they will subtract the deductible from your payout. You may be able to recover this deductible if the other party is at fault. If you are going through the at-fault driver’s company, there will be no deductible. However, they will only pay their percentage of fault if there is shared liability.

In either situation, you should know that you can negotiate the payout on your totaled car.

When negotiating, you first need to know how the insurer has determined the value of your car. They will order a report from a third party, which looks at the most comparable vehicles recently sold in your area.

Each vehicle sale price is then adjusted to make up for differences such as options, mileage and condition. Each number is then weighted into a calculation for your car.

They are required to send you a copy of this value report. It is important that you review this report closely. Look for any mistakes, see if they left any options off your vehicle. Check the conditioning ratings.

If you disagree with their assessment, you might supply photos showing what great shape your paint or interior were in. You can also send in receipts for any recent mechanical work.

After assuring all information is correct, look into the comparable vehicles listed. They should at least be the same year, make and model. But there may be differences in options and mileage. Make sure there are adjustments added if your car was well appointed and/or low mileage.

You can also send them additional vehicles to consider. If you are finding sale listings that skew higher, you can often supply these listings to the insurance company, and they may be able to add them to their report.

As a last option, you may have an appraisal clause in your policy with your own company. This means you can hire an independent appraiser (at your cost), your insurance will do the same, and the appraisers will come to a decision. Do be aware, this number could be higher or lower than any previous offers.

PROS: You get the most payout, the insurance company deals with disposing of the damaged car and all the paperwork involved, you can buy any replacement car you want, or just keep the cash.

CONS: Your damaged car is gone, you aren’t guaranteed to find a similar car to buy.

 2. Keep the car and fix it

For several reasons, you may want to keep the damaged car. This is called an owner-retain option. The insurance company will deduct the salvage value of your car from the settlement.

For example, they owe you $10,000 for your car, and they would have recovered $1,000 selling the salvaged vehicle to a wrecking yard. Your owner-retain option would be to accept $9,000 in payment, and you keep the damaged car.

You can then spend any amount of that money, or your own savings, to fix it. This makes sense if the car is still safe to drive but cosmetic damage has made it a total loss, for older cars that hold sentimental value to you, or if the settlement money isn’t enough to buy a replacement car.

Once you repair the car, you need to follow your state’s rules to obtain a salvage title. Typically, this title will be branded as “salvaged” or “rebuilt.” Some states require professional repairs and a safety inspection, while others have little to no requirements.

You should know that it may not be easy to get car insurance on a salvage title car. Some companies won’t insure them at all, and others will only offer liability insurance, not collision or comprehensive.

PROS: You get to keep the car you’re attached to, you don’t have to find a replacement vehicle, partial repairs might take less money, leaving you with cash leftover.

CONS: You get less cash for your total loss, you have to deal with titling and insuring a salvaged vehicle, you might end up spending more than the car is worth when repairing it.

3. Keep the car and don’t fix it

Similar to the option above, you may want to simply keep the car if it is safe to drive and accept whatever cosmetic damage has deemed it a total loss. This is common with scratches, paint damage or severe dents, such as from hail damage.

This may also be a good option if the payout from the insurance company isn’t enough to buy a replacement car you would be happy with.

PROS: Minimal investment in the totaled car, you can drive a car with cosmetic damage until you decide to replace it later.

CONS: If your car has mechanical damage it may not be safe to drive, you still have to deal with titling and insuring a salvaged vehicle.

4. Keep the car and sell it

When the car insurance company takes a totaled car, they typically sell it at auction. An auto recycler then tears it down and sells the usable parts for a profit.

If you feel you are knowledgeable enough to sell the vehicle on your own, you might be able to get that auction price for yourself. This could be a good option if you own a rare or valuable vehicle that would still fetch a good price as-is.

PROS: You have to potential to get more cash for your car, the new owner will be the one to deal with titling a salvaged vehicle.

CONS: You are not guaranteed to make money, you could end up with less cash, you have to transport and store the damaged car until it is sold.

5. Part it out

You could also take on the whole process yourself. If you are a professional or hobbyist in the automotive field, you may have the skills and tools required to part out a car. There are many options for selling car parts online, such as eBay, Craigslist or Facebook Marketplace.

This can be a good option if you have an enthusiast car or lots of aftermarket parts. Car clubs can be great places to find customers, as they are often full of hobbyists with project vehicles. You could also keep any aftermarket upgrade parts for your replacement vehicle.

PROS: You have the potential to get more cash for your car, you can keep any parts you want.

CONS: Very labor intensive, requires storage space and tools, can take a long time to complete, you will likely need to dispose of the empty frame and damaged parts at the end, along with reporting the vehicle as destroyed.

Many nonprofits will tow the car for free and sell it, and you’ll get a tax deduction for the depreciated value. There are also services that just deal with processing the vehicle, and let you choose which charity receives with proceeds.

PROS: Support a good cause, let someone else deal with the paperwork, you get a tax write-off.

CONS: You don’t get cash for your vehicle beyond what the insurance paid you.

author image
Bryon Bromley

Our team is made up of regular people with insurance policy needs, just like you. We just happen to know a little more about insurance than the average bear.