CarInsurance.com Insights
- You’ll probably pay a higher premium for your first car insurance policy than someone with more driving experience. The price gap is around $2,100 annually for full coverage and $2,300 for state minimum coverage.
- A full coverage policy isn’t a standalone insurance product you can purchase. It’s a bundle that includes liability, collision and comprehensive insurance.
- Rates for newly licensed drivers typically decrease after a year or two, assuming you maintain a clean driving record. The steepest drop for young drivers specifically is between ages 19 and 25.
- If you’re still insured on a parent’s policy, it’s probably a much cheaper option than purchasing your own auto insurance, as long as you still live at that address.
- While first-time car buyers typically pay higher premiums than other drivers, comparing quotes can help you find the cheapest policy. Rates can swing hundreds of dollars between insurers for the same coverage.
Buying your first car is exciting, but it comes with an unexpected homework assignment: making sense of an insurance quote full of terms you’ve never seen before. If you’re wondering what 100/300/100 mean, or how to pick a deductible, you’re not alone.
Car insurance terms are important to know, but here’s what’s equally important: knowing what coverages are actually required, what’s optional and whether your quote is a good price.
This guide will address all of these topics and more, so you can confidently choose the best and cheapest policy for your needs.
How much does it cost for first-time buyers?
On average, first-time car buyers pay $2,100 more for full coverage car insurance than an experienced driver would pay for the same policy. For a state-minimum coverage policy, the gap is slightly larger, at $2,300.
To find the average premiums for a first-time car buyer, CarInsurance.com analyzed Quadrant Information Services rate data and compared newly licensed drivers against drivers with a longer record, using CarInsurance.com’s standard driver profile.
You can see the full cost breakdown in the table below.
| Coverage | Newly licensed driver | Experienced driver | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| State minimum | $3,392/year | $1,134/year | $2,258/year |
| Full coverage (100/300/100; $500 deductibles) | $4,752/year | $2,638/year | $2,114/year |
The main factors behind the cost difference are driving record and driving experience.
Insurance companies price policies on driving history, not the driver’s age. A 40-year-old who’s getting their driver’s license for the very first time faces roughly the same increase as a 16-year-old, because neither one has an established driving record.
As you gain experience behind the wheel, rates typically come down. For teen drivers specifically, the biggest decrease in premium happens between ages 19 and 25.
If your first car insurance quote lands near the newly-licensed driver column, that’s to be expected given your lack of driving history. It doesn’t mean you’re being overcharged and it’s not permanent.
Sophie’s Tip:
A number that big can feel like a red flag. It isn’t — every first-time buyer sees a version of this and it eases the moment you’ve built a clean record.”
What you’re actually buying when you buy car insurance
Car insurance is a contract between you and the insurance company. In exchange for a monthly premium (the cost of your policy), the insurer agrees to cover certain losses. But what’s actually in that policy is what most first-time car buyers struggle with.
Car insurance is legally required in nearly every state and each state has unique liability insurance requirements. You must carry the state minimum coverage to drive your vehicle. If your car is financed or leased, your lender will require you to carry full coverage.
Here’s a breakdown of what a standard car insurance policy can cover:
- Liability: Legally required in every state except New Hampshire.
- Comprehensive: Covers damage from non-collision events, like theft, hail, floods and hitting a deer.
- Collision: Covers damage when you hit another car or object, like a fence or guardrail.
- Full coverage: The name for a policy that includes liability insurance, plus comprehensive and collision coverage together. It’s not a separate product you can buy.
- Optional extras: Many insurers offer optional coverages, like gap insurance, rental car reimbursement and roadside assistance. These are only worth adding if the specific gap they cover is one you’d otherwise pay for yourself.
When deciding on optional coverages, consider what you could realistically afford without them. For example, if your car were stolen tomorrow, could you buy a new one out of pocket? Or, if you hit a tree and the repair bill was $2,000, could you cover that without collision coverage?
If either answer is no, that coverage is protecting money you don’t have, which is the point of having car insurance.
Sophie’s Tip:
Full coverage isn’t the “good” policy, and liability isn’t the “cheap” one — they’re insuring two different things. Liability protects other people from you; full coverage protects your car from liability – and everything else.
Getting your first policy, step-by-step
Buying your first policy comes down to five steps, in this order:
- Know what coverage you need first: Start with your state’s minimum liability requirements, which is the least coverage you can legally carry. If you lease or finance the car, find out whether the lender or leasing company requires comprehensive and collision insurance. Nearly all lenders require full coverage and may cap your deductible. Because state-minimum liability insurance is rarely sufficient to cover a serious accident, choosing higher limits is typically recommended.
- Have your car details ready: When you get a quote, the insurer will ask for your full name, date of birth and driver’s license number for everyone in the household who will drive the car. You’ll also need to provide the car’s vehicle identification number (VIN), which is usually on the dashboard near the windshield and on your registration. The VIN tells the insurer things like the body style and engine size, which get factored into your rate.
- Get at least three insurance quotes: Not every car insurance company is comfortable writing a policy for a new driver with no history, so their rates for the same driver can vary widely. That’s why it’s important to get more than one quote. Make sure to compare the same coverage types, limits, and deductibles for an accurate comparison. And remember that a cheaper quote with lower limits isn’t actually cheaper, it just provides less coverage.
- Read the fine print before you sign: When you buy a car insurance policy, you should read the fine print to understand what’s excluded, such as certain types of drivers, uses of the vehicle, or kinds of damage. You should also double-check that the coverage limits and deductibles are what you asked for. It’s much easier to fix a mistake or error before you sign the contract than after a claim.
- Keep proof of insurance in your car: Once your policy is active, put a copy of your insurance ID card in the glovebox. Many insurers also offer a digital ID card that you can access through the mobile app, but it’s always a good idea to have a paper copy as a backup. If you get pulled over or are involved in an accident, most states require you to show proof of car insurance.
Speak with a friendly agent and get your quote in minutes!
How can first-time buyers save on car insurance?
It’s likely that car insurance will be more expensive the first time you purchase it. Until you prove that you’re a good driver who can be trusted to drive safely, insurance companies will likely require you to pay higher premiums to compensate for the risk of insuring a new driver.
However, there are several ways to reduce car insurance costs. Here are some tips for getting more affordable insurance as a first-time driver:
- Choose the right policy structure: Start with your state’s minimum requirements and add coverage only where needed. Adding optional coverages will raise your premium. Choosing a higher deductible will lower your premium, but only pick a deductible you could comfortably afford to pay right now. If you’re currently insured on a parent’s policy, it’s best to stay there, if possible. Young drivers can save hundreds by being added to a parent’s existing policy rather than purchasing one on their own.
- Compare quotes before you buy: “New drivers need the same core coverage as experienced drivers, but the stakes are often higher due to their inexperience behind the wheel,” said Andrew Femath, senior communications manager at USAA. To find the best rate, aim to compare at least three car insurance quotes and get quotes for the same type of coverage (liability-only or full coverage).
- Enroll in a usage-based insurance (UBI) program: UBI programs use telematics through an in-car device or mobile app to monitor your habits while you drive, such as brake force, acceleration, mileage, length of trips and phone use. When you drive safely, you can earn a discount on your car insurance premium. Conversely, aggressive driving may result in an increase in your premium.
- Ask about discounts: The best way to get insurance discounts is to ask prospective insurers what types of price breaks they offer and how you can qualify for them. Insurers generally offer discounts to policyholders who get good grades in school, bundle their coverage, install safety devices, insure a brand-new car, insure multiple vehicles on the same policy and take a defensive driving course.
Common mistakes first-time buyers make
It’s understandable for newly licensed drivers to run into roadblocks when shopping for car insurance for the first time. Here are the mistakes that show up most and how to avoid them:
- Stopping after the first quote: Premiums for the same driver and coverage can vary widely from one insurer to the next, which is why it’s crucial to compare rates. A first quote is just the first number you got. It doesn’t mean that’s the final price you’re going to pay. Get at least three quotes with matching coverage and limits before you purchase a policy.
- Underinsuring to get a cheaper rate: Liability-only is the cheapest policy you can buy, but it doesn’t cover damage to your own car, and the state minimum limits may not cover the full cost of an accident you cause. Weigh the pros and cons of liability-only versus full coverage based on your personal financial situation, and don’t be tempted to forgo valuable coverage just to get a cheaper monthly rate.
- Only asking about one discount: Many first-time buyers find one discount, such as a good student discount or a bundle, and assume that’s all the savings available. However, discounts can often be stacked, and many insurers won’t apply them unless you ask. Ask each insurer directly what discounts you can qualify for, including ones that might not be advertised on its website.
- Not reading the policy closely: Every car insurance policy has exclusions, which are situations and types of damage it won’t pay for. Certain ones you might not expect. For instance, many policies provide limited coverage when driving your personal vehicle for Uber or Lyft. It’s important to understand what isn’t covered before you sign the policy. You can always ask an agent to walk you through the policy if you have questions.
Final thoughts on car insurance for first-time buyers
Your first car insurance policy will almost always cost more than it will once you have several years of driving experience under your belt. The higher premium is essentially the price of not having a driving record yet, not a sign you did something wrong.
To keep your costs down, make sure to compare at least three quotes. Pick coverage that matches what you’d actually stand to lose in an accident, rather than just the lowest premium. Then, shop around again when the policy renews. Once you’ve had a year or two with a clean record, you’ll likely qualify for a lower premium.
Frequently Asked Questions: First-time car insurance buyers
Do I need my own policy if I only drive occasionally?
Yes. Nearly every state requires car insurance on registered vehicles, regardless of how often you actually drive.
Is it cheaper to stay on a parent’s policy?
In most cases, yes.
“On average, adding a teen driver to a car insurance policy can raise rates by approximately $1,400 a year. And while that isn’t an insignificant amount, putting your teenage driver on a separate policy could cost substantially more,” Femath said. Keep in mind that you can only stay insured on a parent’s policy while you live at the same address. If you move out and take the car with you, you’ll have to buy your own policy.
Will an accident be covered if I buy insurance right after it happens?
No. Insurance doesn’t work retroactively. If you’re in an accident before your policy is active, the claim won’t be covered.
Can roommates share a car insurance policy?
Sometimes, but only if both cars are parked at the same address overnight. If your roommate borrows your car occasionally, it’s a good idea to add them as a driver on your policy. This can raise your premium, but it provides better protection if they’re involved in an accident while driving your car.
Do all insurers cover first-time buyers?
Yes. All insurance companies will insure first-time buyers, as long as you have a valid license. The exception is if you have a serious violation already on your record, such as a DUI. Some insurers don’t cover high-risk drivers, regardless of their driving history.
How can I lower my rate as a first-time buyer?
To reduce your premium, you can bundle your policies, ask about a good student discount, take a defensive driving course and get quotes from at least three insurers. You can also choose a higher deductible, but only if you can comfortably cover that amount out of pocket after a claim.
Resources & Methodology
Sources
- CDC. “Risk Factors for Teen Drivers.” Accessed September 2026.
- Insurance Information Institute. “Auto insurance basics — understanding your coverage.” Accessed September 2026.
- Insurance Information Institute. “Understanding your insurance deductibles.” Accessed September 2026.
- Nationwide. “How credit affects your car insurance premiums.” Accessed September 2026.
Methodology
CarInsurance.com commissioned Quadrant Information Services to get car insurance rates. The rates are based on sample profiles of 40-year-old male and female drivers with full-coverage policies, limits of 100/300/100 and $500 collision and comprehensive deductibles. Read the detailed methodology for more information.
Still have a question? Ask our experts
Get advice from an experienced insurance professional. Our experts will help you navigate your insurance questions with clarity and confidence.
Browse all FAQs
