Indiana's priciest car insurance is found in the northwest cities and suburbs along Lake Michigan, considerably more expensive than in Indianapolis and more rural areas. We've got state car insurance rates for nearly every ZIP code mapped out below, plus a range that shows you how much rates from six major carriers differ in each city and town. You'll see the highest and lowest price among six insurers for the same coverage, so you can see how much you can save by shopping around. You can get a customized rate by entering your ZIP code and choosing among six age groups and three coverage levels.
- Cheap car insurance in Indiana
- Recommended car insurance coverage
- Cheapest car insurance in Indiana by company
- Low cost auto insurance for Indiana drivers with recent accidents
- Who has the cheapest Indiana car insurance for drivers with speeding tickets?
- How much does it cost to add a teen to your policy in Indiana?
- Cheapest Indiana auto insurance for young drivers: Ages 18 to 25
- Senior drivers: Cheap auto insurance for Indiana drivers age 65 to 85
- Car insurance for Indiana drivers with bad credit
- Best car insurance companies in Indiana
- Largest car insurance companies in Indiana
- Indiana Car Insurance Laws
- Average annual car insurance rates for major cities in Indiana
Cheap car insurance in Indiana
Indiana car insurance requirements
| Minimum bodily injury liability | $25,000/$50,000 |
| Minimum property damage liability | $25,000 |
| Under insured Motorists (Bodily Injury) | $50,000 |
Indiana Car Insurance Rates by ZIP Code
| Coverage limits | Average annual rate |
|---|---|
| Liability Only - state minimum | $400 |
| Liability Only - 50/100/50 BI/PD | $424 |
| Full Coverage - 100/300/100 BI/PD $500 Comp/Collision deductible | $964 |
Recommended car insurance coverage
The cheapest car insurance may not provide sufficient protection, so how much insurance should you buy? Bare-bones coverage may be a good choice if you have few assets or have an old car and don’t drive much. But if you have a home and investments, consider buying more insurance. If you don’t, you’re at risk for having your money and house taken to cover the cost of an accident. If you financed your car you will be required to get additional comprehensive and collision coverage.
Use our How Much Car Insurance Do You Need? tool to get a recommendation.
Liability
We recommend you buy more insurance than is required to legally drive a car in your state, especially if you have savings and assets. The more money you have, the more likely you are to be sued following a car accident should your insurance be insufficient to cover all the expenses. If your net worth is:
- less than $50,000, choose at least 50/100/50
- between $50,000 and $100,000, choose at least 100/300/100
- more than $100,000, choose at least 250/500/100
If you're leasing or financing your car, you must get coverage of 100/300/100 or higher.
Collision and comprehensive
Collision coverage pays for damage to your car after an accident that you cause. Comprehensive insurance pays to replace stolen cars and for damages from vandalism, flooding, hail, fire and animal strikes. If your car is:
- less than 10 years old, you should strongly consider buying collision and comprehensive.
- more than 10 years old, only buy collision and comprehensive if your car is worth $3,000 or more, if you couldn’t afford to replace your car if it’s wrecked, or if you just want more protection on your policy.
For drivers in Indiana, collision costs an average of $513 yearly, comprehensive is $146, according to CarInsurance.com rate data. If you buy comp and collision, check our guide to choosing a deductible amount.
Medical coverage (MedPay)
Medical payments coverage can help pay for the medical or funeral expenses of covered drivers and passengers after an accident, regardless of fault, up to $25,000. In most states, including Texas, it's an optional addition to your car insurance policy. MedPay does the following:
- Covers you and your passengers’ medical expenses
- Pays for expenses after health insurance limits are exceeded
- Offers additional protection to insured drivers who are hit by a car while walking or biking
If you and your passengers:
- Don’t have health insurance, or have a plan that doesn’t cover car accidents or has low limits, we recommend that you add medical coverage of at least $5,000 to your car insurance policy.
- Do have health insurance, it’s still a good idea to have medical coverage if you want the best protection in your policy, as it can pay out after your health benefits are maxed out.
Gap insurance
If you don’t own your car outright and have an accident, gap insurance pays the difference between the cash value of your car and the current outstanding balance on your loan or lease.
- If you’re financing your car, your car is less than one year old and you’ve put less than 20 percent down on it, you should buy gap insurance. If not, you don’t need gap insurance.
- If you’re leasing your car, it’s a good idea to buy gap insurance if you aren’t already required to in your lease agreement.
- If you own your car outright, you don’t need gap insurance.
Cheapest car insurance in Indiana by company
Below you'll see average annual rates for Indiana, ranked cheapest to most expensive, for three coverage levels:
- State minimum liability requirements
- Liability limits of $50,000 per person/$100,000 per accident and $50,000 property damage
- Liability of $100,000 per person/$300,000 per accident and $100,000 property damage, with comprehensive and collision at $500 deductible
| Company | State minimum average annual rate | 50/100/50 average annual rate | 100/300/100 average annual rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Allstate Prop & Cas Ins Co | $693 | $697 | $1,569 |
| Geico Cas Co | $294 | $300 | $651 |
| Illinois Farmers Ins Co | $305 | $332 | $748 |
| Nationwide Mut Ins Co | $350 | $379 | $866 |
| Progressive Paloverde Ins Co | $414 | $424 | $854 |
| State Farm Mut Auto Ins Co | $345 | $410 | $1,095 |
Low cost auto insurance for Indiana drivers with recent accidents
Filing an accident claim means you are likely to pay more for your car insurance coverage. However, how much more you pay depends on several factors, and your car insurance company plays is one of those significant factors. Each company assesses risk differently, so that's why the increase after an accident will vary among insurers. Here is how major carriers compare after at-fault accidents for the average Indiana driver with a full coverage policy:
| Company | 1 At-fault property damage accident over $2K | 2 At-fault property damage accident over $2k | At-fault bodily injury accident |
|---|---|---|---|
| Allstate P&C | $1,731 | $3,290 | $1,731 |
| GEICO Cas | $1,194 | $1,947 | $1,194 |
| Illinois Farmers Ins 2.0 | $1,118 | $1,572 | $1,118 |
| Nationwide Mutual | $1,392 | $1,866 | $1,392 |
| Progressive Paloverde | $1,031 | $3,655 | $1,031 |
| State Farm Mutual Auto | $1,088 | $1,099 | $1,088 |
Who has the cheapest Indiana car insurance for drivers with speeding tickets?
If you get a speeding ticket, chances are you'll see an increase in what you pay for car insurance, upon your policy renewal. Typically, you'll pay more for three years. But even with a traffic ticket, comparison shopping can save you money. For instance, you'll see that the difference between the highest rate and the lowest in the table below is more than $1,145, on average, according to CarInsurance.com's rate analysis. That's how much you can save by comparing car insurance companies.
| Company | Average Rate |
|---|---|
| GEICO Cas | $878 |
| State Farm Mutual Auto | $997 |
| Nationwide Mutual | $1,149 |
| Illinois Farmers Ins 2.0 | $1,273 |
| Progressive Paloverde | $1,531 |
| Allstate P&C | $2,023 |
How much does it cost to add a teen to your policy in Indiana?
No matter where you live, adding a new driver to your family policy will hike your rate significantly. In Indiana, you can expect your rate to go up by an average of 140 percent when adding a driver age 16 to your coverage, according to CarInsurance.com rate data. You'll see in the table below how much it costs, on average, to add a teen driver in Indiana, and how major insurers compare on price. Progressive Paloverde had the lowest auto insurance cost for adding a driver age 16 to a full coverage family policy, among insurers surveyed.
| Company | Average Rate | Average Rate after adding female teen | $ Increase (female) | Average Rate after adding male teen | $ Increase (male) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Allstate P&C | $1,731 | $3,758 | $2,028 | $4,439 | $2,708 |
| GEICO Cas | $627 | $1,741 | $1,114 | $2,031 | $1,404 |
| Illinois Farmers Ins 2.0 | $1,050 | $2,488 | $1,438 | $2,611 | $1,562 |
| Nationwide Mutual | $969 | $1,745 | $776 | $2,080 | $1,110 |
| Progressive Paloverde | $969 | $989 | $20 | $989 | $20 |
| State Farm Mutual Auto | $997 | $2,442 | $1,446 | $3,078 | $2,081 |
Cheapest Indiana auto insurance for young drivers: Ages 18 to 25
Enter an age from 18 to 25 to see who has the best rates for young drivers in Indiana, by company.You’ll see in the chart below which car insurance companies have the lowest rates for young drivers buying a full coverage policy. Average car insurance rates by age data shows that drivers typically pay higher rates until age 26, when rates begin to drop as drivers gain more experience on the road. But even young drivers can save money by comparing car insurance rates to see which company has the lowest rates, by qualifying for student discounts and by staying on their parents’ policy as long as possible.
Senior drivers: Cheap auto insurance for Indiana drivers age 65 to 85
Below you can see average rates by company for drivers age 65 and over, buying a full coverage policy. While comparing car insurance quotes is always one of the primary ways to save on coverage, you can also see if you qualify for a mature driver discount or if you can trim rates by taking a defensive driving course.
Car insurance for Indiana drivers with bad credit
Car insurance for drivers with bad credit costs significantly more than it does for those with good credit. Indiana ranks 21st among the worst states for drivers with bad credit, as CarInsurance.com's data analysis shows. Compared to good credit drivers, those in Indiana with bad credit pay 71 percent more, on average. The good news is that you can still shave some money off your coverage costs if you compare car insurance companies. You'll see below that the difference among major insurers is nearly $1,626 for a full coverage policy for a driver with bad credit. That's how much you can potentially save by comparing car insurance quotes.
| Company | Poor credit |
|---|---|
| GEICO Cas | $912 |
| Nationwide Mutual | $1,205 |
| Progressive Paloverde | $1,769 |
| State Farm Mutual Auto | $2,104 |
| Illinois Farmers Ins 2.0 | $2,310 |
| Allstate P&C | $2,538 |
Best car insurance companies in Indiana
Scores are based on Insure.com’s “Best Insurance Companies” customer review survey of 3,700 customers. Policyholders ranked insurers on claims handling, customer service, value, mobile apps/website usefulness and were asked if they would renew their coverage and if they would recommend the company. All scores are out of 100.
| Rank | Company | Score |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | CSAA Insurance Group | 93.43 |
| 2 | USAA | 92.08 |
| 3 | Allstate | 90.18 |
| 4 | Liberty Mutual | 88.21 |
| 5 | American Family | 88.14 |
| 6 | Erie | 87.41 |
| 7 | The Auto Club Group (ACG) - AAA | 87.21 |
| 8 | Auto Club of Southern California (Auto Club Enterprise Insurance Group) | 86.86 |
| 9 | Progressive | 85.66 |
| 10 | Esurance | 85.22 |
| 11 | Geico | 84.11 |
| 12 | Nationwide | 83.80 |
| 13 | Safeco | 83.67 |
| 14 | Farmers | 83.25 |
| 15 | Metlife | 83.11 |
| 16 | State Farm | 82.34 |
| 17 | Travelers | 82.22 |
| 18 | Hartford | 81.19 |
| 19 | The General | 79.03 |
Largest car insurance companies in Indiana
| Rank | Company | Premiums Written | Market Share |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | State Farm Group | 907,710 | 24.05% |
| 2 | Progressive Insurance Group | 428,466 | 11.35% |
| 3 | Allstate Insurance Group | 287,390 | 7.61% |
| 4 | Berkshire Hathaway Insurance Group | 233,428 | 6.18% |
| 5 | Liberty Mutual Insurance Companies | 185,530 | 4.92% |
| 6 | American Family Insurance Group | 171,186 | 4.54% |
| 7 | USAA Group | 98,402 | 2.61% |
| 8 | Nationwide Group | 88,811 | 2.35% |
| 9 | Farmers Insurance Group | 73,150 | 1.94% |
| 10 | Travelers Group | 61,044 | 1.62% |
Source: A.M. Best; State/Line (P/C Lines) - P/C, US; Data as of:November 28, 2018
Indiana Car Insurance Laws
| Roads | Number of Fatal Accidents |
|---|---|
| US-20 | 21 |
| I-70 | 12 |
| US-50 | 11 |
| I-65 | 10 |
| SR-62 | 8 |
| US-6 | 7 |
| US-41S | 7 |
| SR-9 | 7 |
| SR-1 | 7 |
| I-80 | 7 |
Indiana's bodily injury liability requirements of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident and property damage liability coverage of $25,000 are on par with many other states, but if you want to protect your savings and other assets from lawsuits consider raising your liability limits.
Uninsured motorist bodily injury, uninsured motorist property damage and underinsured motorist all must be offered to motorists in the Hoosier State, but these coverages can be rejected in writing.
Tort system: Indiana is not a no-fault insurance state. Indiana is a tort state. When an accident occurs, someone must be found to be at fault, and that person and their car insurance company are responsible for the damages they caused, up to the limits of that person's car insurance policy.
Cancellation and nonrenewal restrictions: Your Indiana auto insurance company may cancel a new policy within the first 60 days for any reason. After 60 days, your insurer may only cancel for certain approved reasons, such as nonpayment of premium or losing your driving privileges. If your auto insurer is not going to renew your policy, it must give you 20 days' advance notice.
Verification of minimum liability insurance: The Bureau of Motor Vehicles (BMV) is required to verify that you have the minimum liability insurance coverage in effect whenever you're involved in:
- A car accident for which the BMV receives an accident report.
- A moving violation that carries license points within one year of receiving two other moving violations that carry points.
- A serious traffic violation, such as a misdemeanor or felony.
- Any violation that carries points by a driver who was previously suspended for failing to provide proof of financial responsibility.
If any of the preceding situations occur, a request for financial responsibility verification will be sent to your mailing address on file with the Indiana BMV. You must then arrange for your car insurance company to file a Certificate of Compliance (COC) electronically with the Indiana BMV. The COC demonstrates that the car you were driving at the time of the accident was insured to the state’s minimum motor vehicle liability protection.
The COC must be processed by the BMV within 40 days of the BMV’s mailing of a request for financial responsibility verification or your license will be suspended. If you miss the deadline, you need to have your car insurance company electronically provide the COC covering the date of the incident or accident and the vehicle involved to get your license back.
SR-22 & SR-50:
- The SR-22 confirms proof of future financial responsibility for drivers who've been convicted of certain offenses. An SR-22 must be filed with the BMV for three years.
- The SR-50 is an affidavit of current insurance and provides the BMV with the beginning and ending dates of your current policy.
Points: Points on your driving record stay active for a two-year period from the conviction date. While after this time period the points are inactive, the offense remains on your record, which means your insurer can continue to rate on it.
Repeat offenders: If the BMV finds you have committed repeat traffic violations over a 10-year-period it will classify you as a habitual traffic violator. The habitual traffic violator law allows the BMV to suspend the license of a repeat offender for five years, 10 years or life.
Uninsured motorist penalties for Indiana: When caught driving with no insurance in Indiana, you may be fined up to $1,000, your license may be suspended and you may be required to file an SR-22 form.
Expired license plates: The fine for driving with expired license plates in Indiana is normally around $150.
Electronic proof of insurance: Indiana law allows drivers to show proof of insurance during a traffic stop on a smartphone. It is one of 31 states that does so.
Average annual car insurance rates for major cities in Indiana
Below you'll see how average annual rates for several of the largest cities in the state compare to state and national averages. Rates are for coverage of $100,000 per person/$300,000 per accident in liability and $50,000 of property damage coverage, with comprehensive and collision carrying a $500 deductible.
| City | Average Premium |
|---|---|
| Bloomington | $968 |
| Evansville | $1,076 |
| Fort Wayne | $993 |
| Indianapolis | $1,160 |
| South Bend | $969 |
| Indiana | $1,080 |
| National | $1,679 |