Standing on the lot at the dealership, you’re weighing your options between two cars: one has a gas cap and the other has a charging port. All else being equal, if you want to control your insurance costs, which one do you pick? 

The national average cost to insure an electric car is $3,708 per year, or $817 higher than the $2,891 average for gas models, according to a CarInsurance.com analysis of Quadrant Information Services data. But those figures won’t help you decide on the two vehicles in front of you. On models sold in both gas and electric versions, the electric premium runs from less than $100 to more than $850, and your insurer choice could swing the price even more.

We’ll show you how to narrow down projected costs from the national average down to your state, your insurer and the specific car you’re considering. Those last two are the variables that you can control.

How much does it cost to insure an electric car vs. a gas car?

The average cost to insure an electric vehicle is $3,708 per year or $309 per month with full coverage (liability plus collision and comprehensive). The average full-coverage quote for a gas vehicle was $2,891 per year, or $241 per month.  The difference works out to $817 per year, or $68 more per month. Both EV and gas rates were based on the same driver profile and coverage limits, so the difference comes down to the car. 

In our analysis, electric rates run from $2,095 to $6,207, and gas rates from $1,787 to $4,934, with the two ranges overlapping almost completely. On models sold in both gas and electric versions, the rate difference ranged from $84 to $854 per year, about a tenfold spread.

Part of the reason for higher averages is that insurers factor in the cost of repairing or replacing a vehicle, and there aren’t many low-budget options for EVs. National averages reflect the cars that are available, not necessarily what going electric does for a particular model.

Here’s how the national averages break down by billing period:

Vehicle typeAnnual averageSix-month averageMonthly average
Electric$3,708$1,854$309
Gas$2,891$1,446$241
Difference$817$408$68

Basing your budget on category averages leaves out those variations across models, so price out the specific car you’re considering, starting with your state.

EV insurance cost by state: where the gap is widest and narrowest

Per dollar, the electric premium is widest in Louisiana, at an additional $1,273, and lowest in Hawaii, at just $388. As a percentage increase, the biggest gap is 39%, found in both New Hampshire and Pennsylvania, and the lowest is 15%, found in Georgia.

A high-cost state doesn’t always mean a more expensive electric premium. In Florida, the average cost to insure gas cars is $3,745, among the highest in the country. But its electric premium is just $551 or 16% per year. And in Vermont, where insurance rates average $1,866 for gas vehicles, the electric premium is 36%.

Car insurance base rates vary from state to state, affected by each one’s unique climate risks, auto theft rates, insurance regulations and repair costs. EV surcharges and other electric car costs vary by state, too. These are added because EV drivers don’t need to fuel up with gas, which typically carries a gas tax. EV fees range from $50 in Hawaii to $270 in New Jersey, according to the Tax Foundation. The result is that your insurance cost to drive an EV vs. a gas-powered car depends a lot on the state you live in.

Where you live can change the electric premium by more than $880 a year, from $388 in Hawaii to $1,273 in Louisiana.

Check your own state before assuming the national gap applies to you.

State  Electric annual average rate Gas annual average rate Difference $ Difference %
Alaska$3,301$2,713$58822%
Alabama$3,340$2,444$89637%
Arkansas$4,357$3,341$1,01630%
Arizona$3,716$3,004$71224%
California$4,725$3,687$1,03828%
Colorado$4,282$3,405$87726%
Connecticut$4,267$3,271$99630%
Washington, D.C.$4,959$3,745$1,21432%
Delaware$4,121$3,215$90628%
Florida$4,026$3,475$55116%
Georgia$3,601$3,133$46815%
Hawaii$2,095$1,707$38823%
Iowa$3,416$2,474$94238%
Idaho$2,412$1,938$47424%
Illinois$2,991$2,422$56923%
Indiana$2,516$1,981$53527%
Kansas$3,842$2,803$1,03937%
Kentucky$4,432$3,345$1,08732%
Louisiana$6,207$4,934$1,27326%
Massachusetts$3,082$2,323$75933%
Maryland$4,176$3,039$1,13737%
Maine$2,342$1,787$55531%
Michigan$5,056$3,813$1,24333%
Minnesota$3,467$2,683$78429%
Missouri$3,668$2,846$82229%
Mississippi$4,233$3,242$99131%
Montana$3,715$2,730$98536%
North Carolina$3,155$2,455$70029%
North Dakota$3,079$2,364$71530%
Nebraska$3,838$2,969$86929%
New Hampshire$2,615$1,880$73539%
New Jersey$4,033$3,294$73922%
New Mexico$3,718$2,818$90032%
Nevada$4,640$3,850$79021%
New York$4,037$3,116$92130%
Ohio$2,421$1,924$49726%
Oklahoma$3,918$3,283$63519%
Oregon$3,023$2,504$51921%
Pennsylvania$3,847$2,774$1,07339%
Rhode Island$4,095$3,049$1,04634%
South Carolina$4,099$3,381$71821%
South Dakota$4,225$3,122$1,10335%
Tennessee$3,398$2,505$89336%
Texas$4,048$3,382$66620%
Utah$2,825$2,296$52923%
Virginia$3,120$2,391$72930%
Vermont$2,546$1,866$68036%
Washington$2,854$2,377$47720%
Wisconsin$3,698$2,717$98136%
West Virginia$3,263$2,507$75630%
Wyoming$3,056$2,226$83037%

Which insurance companies are cheapest for electric cars?

Travelers is the cheapest insurer for electric cars among widely available providers, averaging $2,306 per year ($192 per month), according to our analysis. It also carries the smallest EV premium of the insurers we compared, at $350 above the average for a gas-powered car. Farmers charges the most at $5,100 a year for an EV and has the widest gap at $1,283. 

That spread indicates that insurers can’t agree on what an EV should cost to insure. The difference between the rates for an EV from the cheapest and most expensive insurers is $2,794. The same driver profile, the same vehicle, but one company adds $350 for going electric and the other adds $1,283. Travelers’ average EV rate was also lower than the average gas rate at every other widely available carrier in our analysis.

Your choice of insurer can move your EV premium by $2,794 a year — more than three times the gap between electric and gas cars.

Keep in mind that you need to weigh both percentage increase and the dollar amount. For instance, Allstate’s electric premium is a modest 20%, but because its base rates are high, that still adds $769 a year.

Some insurers offer discounts for so-called “green” or environmentally friendly vehicles. Travelers says you could save on leased or owned hybrid vehicles, for example. But true EV discounts are uncommon, and even a generous discount may not beat the price difference between two carriers. Get quotes on both versions of the same car so you’re comparing like for like. 

Here’s what each major insurer charges, on average, to cover an electric car vs. a gas car:

InsurerAverage electric annual rateAverage gas annual rateDifference $Difference %
Allstate$4,570$3,801$76920%
Farmers$5,100$3,817$1,28334%
GEICO$3,146$2,430$71629%
Nationwide$3,250$2,614$63624%
Progressive$3,475$2,697$77829%
State Farm$3,155$2,505$65026%
Travelers$2,306$1,956$35018%
USAA*$2,922$2,059$86342%

*Note that USAA car insurance is limited to eligible military members, veterans and their families.

An insurer that offers competitive rates on a gas car may not offer the same for EVs, so shopping for the electric quote is key.

Sophie’s Next Step

Get quotes on both versions of the car from the same three carriers. Same day, same coverage. That’s the only comparison that tells you anything.

Speak with a friendly agent and get your quote in minutes!

Call (833) 708-5448
max-avatar
Max Available Now
carl-avatar
Carl Available Now
lori-avatar
Lori Available Now
rita-avatar
Rita Available Now

Electric vs. gas versions of the same car: what each one costs to insure

Some carmakers sell models with both gas and electric powertrain options, which lets you compare insurance costs while keeping the model constant. In our analysis of those models, the electric version costs between $84 and $854 more per year to insure. The Hyundai Kona is at the low end, where going electric adds about $7 to the average monthly bill. The GMC Sierra 1500 is at the high end, at about $71. 

Then there’s the Genesis G80: the spread between gas and electric versions of this luxury sedan is just $90, strong evidence there’s no flat electric premium across the board.

The widest gaps are mostly among full-size pickups and large SUVs, including the Ford F-150, Chevrolet Blazer, Chevy Silverado 1500 and the GMC Sierra 1500 and their electric counterparts. 

Despite the hefty EV surcharge, the electric versions don’t necessarily cost more in claims payouts. For example, according to insurance loss data from the Highway Loss Data Institute, the Chevrolet Blazer EV sees “substantially better than average” comprehensive claims losses of -55% compared to the gas-powered version (-29%, “better than average”). The electric F-150 Lightning saw substantially better than average losses in personal injury and medical payments claims, outperforming all trim levels of the F-150. 

Here’s what each model costs to insure in gas and electric versions, sorted from smallest to largest difference:

Model (electric version)Gas annual rateElectric annual rateDifference $Difference %Segment
Hyundai Kona (Kona Electric)$2,460$2,544$843%Subcompact SUV
Genesis G80 (Electrified G80)$4,083$4,173$902%Luxury midsize sedan
Mini Countryman (Countryman SE ALL4)$2,587$2,824$2379%Subcompact SUV
Chevrolet Equinox (Equinox EV)$2,488$2,772$28411%Compact SUV
Genesis GV70 (Electrified GV70)$3,181$3,520$33911%Luxury compact SUV
Ford F-150 (F-150 Lightning)$2,644$3,064$42016%Full-size pickup
Chevrolet Blazer (Blazer EV)$2,650$3,261$61123%Midsize SUV
Chevrolet Silverado 1500 (Silverado EV)$2,702$3,526$82430%Full-size pickup
GMC Sierra 1500 (Sierra EV)$2,761$3,615$85431%Full-size pickup
Insurance rates by car model

Insurance rates by car model

Confidential All the information you provide for this calculator will be kept confidential. We will not ask you for any information that can be used to contact you unless you request a quote.
Car is already added..!!
Confidential All the information you provide for this calculator will be kept confidential. We will not ask you for any information that can be used to contact you unless you request a quote.

Is a hybrid cheaper to insure than an electric car?

Hybrids may offer a sweet spot between EV insurance rates and gas-powered fuel costs. Our analysis shows that conventional hybrids add between $82 and $196 per year to your insurance bill. Plug-in hybrids add $102 to $597. Compared to the nearly $900 upper limit of EVs, hybrids are the more predictable choice. However, they’re not always the cheapest.

First, a quick breakdown of the three tiers of gas alternatives:

  • Conventional hybrids pair a gas engine with a small battery that recharges while you drive.
  • Plug-in hybrids have a larger battery you charge at home. 
  • Full electric vehicles run on battery alone, no gas.

Insurance ranges for these three tiers overlap, perhaps more than you might expect. A plug-in hybrid could cost the same as a conventional hybrid to insure, such as with the Mitsubishi Outlander, which adds $102. They could also land closer to the upper end of the full electric range, as with the Jeep Grand Cherokee 4xe, which adds $597. Then there are full electric versions that undercut both, like the Hyundai Kona, which adds just $84.

Here’s how the tiers compare, using two example models from each:

Powertrain tierModelGas annual rateEV annual rateDifference $
Conventional hybridToyota Corolla Cross$2,418$2,500$82
Conventional hybridHonda CR-V$2,310$2,506$196
Plug-in hybridMitsubishi Outlander$2,917$3,019$102
Plug-in hybridJeep Grand Cherokee 4xe$2,680$3,277$597
Full electricHyundai Kona$2,460$2,544$84
Full electricGMC Sierra 1500$2,761$3,615$854

At the pump, the tradeoff works the other way. The tier that costs the least to insure (gas) also costs you the most on fuel. Full electric cars can save you more on gas, but there’s a bigger variation in rate premium, depending on the model you choose. If the insurance number is the only thing preventing you from going electric, a conventional hybrid offers a middle path: fuel savings for a minimal increase in rate.

See model-by-model figures for hybrid insurance costs and the cheapest EVs and hybrids to insure.

Does car insurance cover an electric car battery?

Yes, full coverage can protect the battery in your EV, and you don’t need to add a separate policy. Collision coverage can pay to replace a battery pack damaged in a crash and comprehensive can help if the damage was caused by a covered event other than a collision, such as fire or theft. The battery is covered the same way as the rest of the parts in your car.

One thing that people sometimes find confusing is the difference between the warranty and your insurance and which one pays to replace the battery if it doesn’t hold a charge. Here’s how to think about it:

  • A manufacturer’s warranty covers battery defects and loss of capacity over time, typically covering the first eight years or 100,000 miles. 
  • Your car insurance covers sudden, unexpected loss or damage.

Even if the battery is under warranty, the cost of replacement can be steep, and damage to it can result in a total loss. Total loss occurs when the insurer estimates that the cost to repair the vehicle exceeds the cost to replace it and pays out the value instead.

Before you buy a policy, ask your agent three questions to see how your policy would cover a damaged EV battery:

  • Is a damaged battery paid out at the replacement cost or the actual cash value (ACV)?
  • Do I need a battery inspection after a collision?
  • Is your home charger covered? (It usually falls under homeowners insurance, not auto.)

If you’re financing the car, be aware that EVs can lose value quickly. Gap insurance could help you cover the difference after a claim.

Sophie’s Says

Your warranty covers a battery that wears out. Your insurance covers a battery that gets wrecked. People find out these are different things at the worst possible moment.

Are electric cars cheaper to own than gas cars once you add insurance?

They can be. EVs are typically cheaper to own in terms of running costs, at about 6.1 cents per mile compared to 10.1 cents per mile for gas, according to Department of Energy research. At 15,000 miles per year, that’s about $600 in savings. It’s also generally cheaper to charge an EV at home compared to fueling up a gas vehicle at the pump.

This table shows three EVs and the differences in the costs of insuring, fueling and maintaining them compared to their gas-powered versions.

ModelInsurance cost Fuel savings Maintenance savingsNet running-cost difference
Hyundai Kona EV+$84$1,058$600-$1,574
Chevrolet Equinox EV+$284$1,279$600-$1,595
GMC Sierra 1500+$854$1,618$600-$1,364

Choosing an EV over a gas model won’t work for everyone. People without home charging will, for example, spend more to charge at commercially available stations. Those who drive less than 8,000 miles per year will see much smaller fuel savings, which is more likely to be overrun by the EV premium. Electric pickups tend to have much higher EV premiums, which eat up a larger share of any fuel savings.

One trend worth pointing out: the repair-cost differences between electric and gas vehicles reached a record low in mid-2026, according to claims-data firm Mitchell, sitting at $729. Meanwhile, total-loss rates for EVs are within range of gas-powered vehicles: 13% compared to 12%, according to Mitchell’s May 2026 report.

The best way to decide between gas and EV is to request a quote for both versions of the car from the same insurer. Don’t wait until you’ve signed for a new vehicle — this is price context you need before the purchase, not after. See other costs of EV ownership so you have all the numbers.

Conclusion

There really is a premium for insuring electric vehicles and it can run into the hundreds of dollars. However, the gap is largest for the largest vehicles, like full-size pickups and fuel and maintenance savings may offset it. The biggest factors that affect the cost (the vehicle and the insurer) are ones you choose, so run the numbers before your purchase.

Frequently Asked Questions: EVs vs. gas cars

Why do some electric pickups cost so much more to insure?

Rates are higher for electric pickups for a few reasons. First, these vehicles must carry much larger battery packs than standard EV sedans, increasing repair costs. Vehicle values are also typically higher than those of their gasoline counterparts, while fewer repair centers can provide the specialized service required to repair them after a crash. Two examples of this difference are the Ford F-150 ($2,644 for gas, $3,064 for EV) and the GMC Sierra ($2,761 for gas, $3,615 for EV).

Which electric cars are cheapest to insure?

Among models sold in both gas or hybrid and electric versions, the cheapest EVs to insure are the Hyundai Kona ($2,544), Kia Niro ($2,654), Chevrolet Equinox ($2,772), Mini Countryman ($2,824) and the Chevrolet Blazer ($3,261), according to our analysis. 

Are hybrids cheaper to insure than electric cars?

Yes, usually. Conventional hybrids add relatively little to the average full coverage car insurance bill. Most conventional hybrids cost less than $200 per year more than their gas versions, according to our analysis. However, plug-in hybrids typically add more, usually between $102 and $597.

Do I need special insurance for an electric car?

No, you don’t need special electric vehicle insurance for your EV. The same coverage types (liability, collision and comprehensive) cover an EV the same way they do a gas-powered vehicle. That means you can buy the same type of policy for an EV that you usually would.

Does a Tesla cost more to insure than other electric cars?

It depends on the model. We found that insuring a Tesla costs an average of $4,140 a year for full coverage, which is higher than the average cost of insuring an EV ($3,708). However, it’s slightly lower than the average annual rate to insure the electric version of the Genesis G80 luxury sedan ($4,173). Narrow it down to the Tesla Model 3, however, and the average cost falls to $3,466.

Resources & Methodology

Resources

  1. Tax Foundation. “Electric Vehicle Tax Treatment by State, 2026.” Accessed November 2026.
  2. National Insurance Crime Bureau. “Vehicle Thefts Experience Historic Decline.”Accessed November 2026.
  3. National Caucus of Environmental Legislators. “From Risk to Resilience: How States Are Approaching Insurance and Climate Risk in 2026.” Accessed November 2026.
  4. Travelers. “Car Insurance Discounts.” Accessed November 2026.
  5. Highway Loss Data Institute. “Insurance losses by make and model.” Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. Accessed November 2026.

View More

  1. U.S. Department of Energy. “Maintenance and Safety of Electric Vehicles.” Alternative Fuels Data Center. Accessed October 2026.
  2. U.S. Department of Energy, Transportation Technologies Office. “FOTW #1190, June 14, 2021: Battery-Electric Vehicles Have Lower Scheduled Maintenance Costs than Other Light-Duty Vehicles.” 2021. Accessed October 2026.
  3. U.S. Department of Energy. “Clean Cities and Communities Alternative Fuel Price Report, July 2026.” Alternative Fuels Data Center. Accessed October 2026.
  4. U.S. Energy Information Administration. “Average Price of Electricity to Ultimate Customers by End-Use Sector, by State.” Table 5.6.A. Electric Power Monthly. Accessed October 2026.
  5. U.S. Department of Energy. “Vehicle Cost Calculator.” Alternative Fuels Data Center. Accessed October 2026.
  6. Mitchell. “Plugged-In: EV Collision Insights Q2 2026.” Accessed October 2026.
  7. Mitchell. “Hybrid Vehicle Collision Claims Hit Record High in First Quarter as BEV Claims Level Off.” Accessed October 2026.

Methodology

Rates based on CarInsurance.com analysis of 2026 Quadrant Information Services data. Rates are for a 40-year-old male driver with a 12-mile commute and 10,000 annual miles. Coverage is 100/300/100 liability with $500 collision and comprehensive deductibles, priced on new vehicles across all 50 states and Washington, D.C.

Matched models are nameplates sold in both gas and electric versions. Rates compare the same nameplate, which may include different trim levels. 

Follow CarInsurance.com on Google
Authors Still have a question? Ask our experts

Get advice from an experienced insurance professional. Our experts will help you navigate your insurance questions with clarity and confidence.

Browse all FAQs
Please enter a valid input Min 50 to max 250 characters are allowed. Only (& ? , .) characters are allowed.
All information provided will remain confidential.
Please enter a valid input
Error: Security check failed
Thank You, Your message has been received. Our team of auto insurance experts typically answers questions within five working days. Note that due to the volume of questions we receive, not all may be answered. You are a bot!
↻ Ask another question
Meet our editorial team
Headshot of Mary Beth Eastman Mary Beth EastmanContributing Researcher
Mary Beth Eastman is an insurance and personal finance expert covering auto, home and life insurance as well as mortgages, loans and credit. Her work has appeared in leading outlets including U.S. News & World Report and The Wall Street Journal, where she provides readers with trusted, expert-driven guidance.
Headshot of Laura Longero Laura LongeroEditor-in-Chief
Laura Longero is the editor-in-chief of CarInsurance.com and a Nevada-based insurance expert. With more than 15 years of experience simplifying complex financial and insurance topics, she provides clear, trustworthy guidance to help drivers make confident coverage decisions. She serves as a media spokesperson for CarInsurance.com and has been featured in Consumer Affairs, MotorTrend and Business Insider, and completed the pre-licensing course in Personal Lines Property & Casualty Insurance.