The drive to legalize the use of marijuana has spread across the country in recent years. At least 38 states have made it lawful to use the substance for medical or recreational purposes, or both.
In the past year, five states had proposals on the ballot to legalize recreational marijuana, with voters approving the expansion in Maryland and Missouri, but rejecting proposals in Arkansas, North Dakota and South Dakota.
But as people use marijuana more frequently and openly, the risks around driving while under the influence grow. And the prospect of more crashes linked to marijuana use also is on the rise.
“As recreational marijuana becomes more widely available, there are concerns about the potential dangers of driving under the influence,” says Pat Aussem, associate vice president of consumer clinical content development at Partnership to End Addiction, a New York nonprofit.
That reality can impact the rates you pay for car insurance.
- 38 states and the District of Columbia allow the use of marijuana for medical purposes.
- States that legalized recreational marijuana saw increased collision claim frequency by 4% from 2012 to 2019.
- Following a DUI, car insurance rates jump by 80% on average and rates tend to jump from an average of $1,447 to $2,610.
- Following a DUI, car insurance rates double on average. The national average cost of a full coverage policy is $2,076 a year, but after a DUI, it’s $4,291.
How does marijuana affect drivers?
Marijuana and driving do not mix. According to the National Institute on Drug Abuse, driving under the influence of this substance impairs your:
- Judgment
- Motor coordination
- Reaction time
Having THC – the psychoactive component in marijuana – in your body can reduce your ability to drive a car safely. In fact, marijuana is the illegal drug that shows up most often in the blood of drivers involved in crashes, according to the National Institute of Drug Abuse.
Those with THC in their blood are anywhere from three to seven times more likely to be responsible for a crash than those who drive unimpaired by any substance.
At a glanceThere is evidence of an increase in the accident rate since marijuana was legalized in several states.
An examination by the Highway Loss Data Institute of insurance records found that legalizing retail marijuana sales in four states – Colorado, Nevada, Oregon and Washington – increased collision claim frequency by 4% compared with other Western states from 2012-19.
A separate study conducted by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety found that the use of recreational marijuana was associated with a 6.5% increase in injury crash rates and a 2.3% increase in fatal crashes from 2009-19.
Aussem says people must understand the risks of driving while under the influence of marijuana. It is imperative to understand how long they should wait before driving after smoking cannabis or consuming edibles.
Learn more about how weed affects car insurance rates in states where it’s legal
How is marijuana regulated at the state and federal levels?
Laws related to marijuana use differ sharply between how the federal government views the substance and how various states treat recreational and medicinal use.
The federal view is simple and straightforward: All marijuana use remains prohibited. However, that is often not the case at the state level. How many states have legalized marijuana? In truth, marijuana laws by state vary.
The overwhelming number of states – 38 – allow the use of marijuana for medical purposes. Meanwhile, 21 states and the District of Columbia allow the use of marijuana for recreational purposes.
The Colorado Department of Transportation’s blog says that people who have consumed marijuana should do the following:
- Wait at least six hours after smoking marijuana containing less than 35 mg THC before driving or biking. If you have smoked more than 35 mg, wait longer.
- Wait at least eight hours after eating or drinking marijuana containing less than 18 mg THC before driving or biking. If you have consumed more than 18 mg or if you have consumed alcohol as well, wait even longer.
What are per se laws regarding marijuana?
A per se law prevents people from legally driving if they have specific amounts of a drug in their bodies.
For marijuana, per se laws define impairment as a certain amount of THC in a person’s blood. Aussem says this varies from state to state but is usually between 2 ng/ml to 5 ng/ml.
“There is a tremendous debate as to whether these limits are accurate in reflecting impairment due to the different ways in which people metabolize the drug,” Aussem says.
Currently, 17 states have zero tolerance or non-zero per se laws for marijuana, according to the Governors Highway Safety Association:
- Ten states have zero tolerance for THC (the psychoactive compound that makes people feel “high”) or a metabolite (the molecule into which THC breaks down).
- Three states have zero tolerance for THC but no restriction on metabolites.
- Four states have specific per se limits for THC.
A single state – Colorado – has a permissible inference law for THC.
What are marijuana impairment laws and how are they different from BAC testing?
Unlike per se laws, impairment laws go beyond the substance in your system and focus on driving quality and behavior when you are stopped.
“Impairment laws typically rely on a drug recognition expert to assess an individual for impairment using a 12-step protocol,” Aussem says.
This includes items such as:
- Blood-alcohol content
- A statement from the arresting officer
- A reading of the driver’s pulse
- Examination of the driver’s pupils
- Divided-attention tests
Testing for the presence of THC in your blood can be challenging. And some states use oral fluid testing “to confirm that substances are in a person’s system at the time of the arrest.”
The Insurance Information Institute says there is no equivalent of a “breathalyzer” test for testing impairment from marijuana. While some have suggested that testing saliva may reveal a driver’s THC levels during stops, others say such results cannot accurately indicate a driver’s level of impairment.
The AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety notes that the best way to test a person’s THC levels is to take a blood sample. However, that reality “has practical and constitutional implications for roadside testing.”
In addition, THC metabolizes quickly, so collection typically needs to happen within an hour of the person driving.
Aussem says better testing methods are needed to identify the level of impairment in people who use marijuana and drive. She says statistics about marijuana use and driving accidents can be misleading because finding the presence of cannabis in a driver’s system does not mean the drug played a role in the crash.
“Someone could use cannabis on Friday night and get into an accident on Monday morning,” Aussem says. “THC would still be in the person’s system, but it would not be a reason for impairment in this scenario.”
Marijuana laws per state: Which states are per se and which are impairment states?
Here is a breakdown of which states have per se laws and those that follow an impairment model:
| States | Marijuana Laws |
|---|---|
| Alabama | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Alaska | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Arizona | Zero tolerance for THC and metabolites |
| Arkansas | No specific law for marijuana use |
| California | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Colorado | Permissible inference for THC (5 ng) |
| Connecticut | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Delaware | Zero tolerance for THC and metabolites |
| District of Columbia | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Florida | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Georgia | Zero tolerance for THC and metabolites |
| Hawaii | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Idaho | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Illinois | THC per se (5 ng) |
| Indiana | Zero tolerance for THC and metabolites |
| Iowa | Zero tolerance for THC |
| Kansas | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Kentucky | Zero tolerance for THC |
| Louisiana | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Maine | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Maryland | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Massachusetts | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Michigan | Zero tolerance for THC |
| Minnesota | Zero tolerance for THC |
| Mississippi | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Missouri | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Montana | THC per se (5 ng) |
| Nebraska | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Nevada | THC per se (2 ng) for felony violations |
| New Hampshire | No specific law for marijuana use |
| New Jersey | No specific law for marijuana use |
| New Mexico | No specific law for marijuana use |
| New York | No specific law for marijuana use |
| North Carolina | Zero tolerance for THC |
| North Dakota | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Ohio | THC per se (2 ng) |
| Oklahoma | Zero tolerance for THC and metabolites |
| Oregon | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Pennsylvania | Zero tolerance for THC and metabolites |
| Rhode Island | Zero tolerance for THC and metabolites |
| South Carolina | No specific law for marijuana use |
| South Dakota | Zero tolerance for THC and metabolites |
| Tennessee | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Texas | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Utah | Zero tolerance for THC and metabolites |
| Vermont | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Virginia | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Washington | THC per se (5 ng) |
| West Virginia | No specific law for marijuana use |
| Wisconsin | Zero tolerance for delta-9-THC |
| Wyoming | No specific law for marijuana use |
How will a DUI affect auto insurance rates?
A DUI can significantly impact how much you pay for auto insurance. In fact, following a DUI, your can expect your car insurance to double, and stay that way for three years.
The national average cost of a full coverage policy is $2,076 a year. After a DUI, the average cost of car insurance jumps to $4,291.
The Insurance Information Institute notes that if the spread of marijuana use spreads to more states and becomes an increasing factor in accidents, it could cause auto insurance rates to increase for everyone to keep up with mounting claims costs.
Learn more: DUI insurance: Average rates by state and company
Sources
Cannabis (Marijuana) Research Report by NIDA
State Medical Cannabis Laws by NCSL
How Long Does Marijuana Stay in Your System Explained by Verywell Mind
Drug-Impaired Driving Data – U.S. Map by GHSA
Driving under the Influence Per Se Explained by New Mexico Criminal Law
Marijuana and Impaired Driving Explained by III
Major Issues Regarding the Impacts of Alcohol and Marijuana on Driving Explained by FTS
Ask the Insurance Expert
Laura Longero
Executive Editor
Laura is an award-winning editor with experience in content and communications covering auto insurance and personal finance. She has written for several media outlets, including the USA Today Network. She most recently worked in the public sector for the Nevada Department of Transportation.
Ask the Insurance Expert
John McCormick
Editorial Director
John is the editorial director for CarInsurance.com, Insurance.com and Insure.com. Before joining QuinStreet, John was a deputy editor at The Wall Street Journal and had been an editor and reporter at a number of other media outlets where he covered insurance, personal finance, and technology.
Ask the Insurance Expert
Leslie Kasperowicz
Managing Editor
Leslie Kasperowicz is an insurance educator and content creation professional with nearly two decades of experience first directly in the insurance industry at Farmers Insurance and then as a writer, researcher, and educator for insurance shoppers writing for sites like ExpertInsuranceReviews.com and InsuranceHotline.com and managing content, now at CarInsurance.com.
Ask the Insurance Expert
Nupur Gambhir
Managing Editor
Nupur Gambhir is a content editor and licensed life, health, and disability insurance expert. She has extensive experience bringing brands to life and has built award-nominated campaigns for travel and tech. Her insurance expertise has been featured in Bloomberg News, Forbes Advisor, CNET, Fortune, Slate, Real Simple, Lifehacker, The Financial Gym, and the end-of-life planning service.