CarInsurance.com Insights
- Car insurance rates are rising nationwide, even for safe drivers — premiums are increasing due to overall market pressures like inflation and higher claim costs, not just individual driving history.
- Inflation and repair costs drive much of the increase — vehicles are more expensive to fix or replace, and insurers pass those costs onto policyholders.
- Your personal profile still matters — factors like accidents, traffic violations, credit score, vehicle type, and adding drivers can raise your premium.
- Location changes can affect rates — where you live (ZIP code) influences premiums because insurers factor in regional accident, theft, and weather risk.
- Proactive steps can help limit future increases — shopping for quotes, raising deductibles, adjusting coverage levels, and asking about discounts are effective strategies.
Car insurance premiums are climbing for most drivers in 2026 — even those with clean records. The increase is driven by a combination of personal risk factors and broader industry trends that are pushing costs higher across the board.
“Right now, insurance companies are facing increasing pressures. The average cost per liability claim has increased by 54% since 2019. Driving violations have increased 17% year-over-year. Additionally, inflation, rising parts and labor costs and more complex vehicles are contributing to higher claim costs,” says Prateek Agarwal, the co-founder of Best Online Traffic School in California.
As a result of these changing market conditions, many insurance companies have raised premiums for all drivers to offset their financial losses.
Why your car insurance rates may be increasing
Car insurance rates are on the rise for most drivers. While there’s no single cause to blame for the increase in auto insurance rates, several factors can come into play.
Below is a look at some of the reasons car insurance costs are rising.
What personal factors cause car insurance rates to go up?
While industry-wide trends play a role, your individual risk profile has a direct impact on what you pay. Here are the most common personal factors that can cause your premium to increase.
Accidents or claims on your record
A history of accidents or claims signals a higher risk to insurers. Drivers with multiple claims in their past typically pay more because insurance companies expect them to cost more in the future.
Moving violations or tickets
Insurers reward clean driving records with lower premiums. Speeding tickets, moving violations and DUIs all push rates higher because they suggest a greater likelihood of future claims.
A change of address or ZIP code
Where you park your car matters. Moving to a new state, city or even a different neighborhood can significantly change your premium. Areas with higher traffic density, theft rates or accident frequency cost more to insure. You can check car insurance rates by state to see how your location compares.
Adding drivers or vehicles to your policy
More drivers and vehicles on your policy means more exposure for the insurer — and a higher premium. Teen drivers and brand-new vehicles are especially expensive to add.
A drop in your credit score
In most states, insurers factor your credit score into your premium. Drivers with excellent credit generally pay the lowest rates, while those with poor credit pay significantly more.
The type and age of your vehicle
Brand-new cars typically cost more to insure than older models that have already depreciated. Luxury vehicles carry higher rates than economy cars because they’re more expensive to repair or replace. You can compare car insurance rates by make and model to see where your vehicle falls.
Climate change and natural disaster risk
Even the cheapest car insurance companies have been forced to raise premiums because of natural disasters driven by climate change. When insurers pay expensive claims in areas affected by fires or hurricanes, they often raise premiums across entire regions to compensate for their financial losses.
What other drivers are saying about car insurance rates
Here’s what a motorist with a slightly older car had to say on Reddit about climbing premiums:
“I have a 2019 Camry. I’ve had State Farm insurance the past 2 years. Every renewal, my insurance premiums have gone up. From $457 to 563 to 573 to 681 (for 6 months). I’ve had no tickets for 5+ years and no at-fault claims ever. I know medical insurance claims have been going up appreciably the past few years. Is auto insurance mirroring that or is there something else at issue here?”
Several other drivers echoed this post with complaints about recent rate hikes. Some suggested requesting new rate quotes from different carriers every three months; others advised asking your carrier about every possible discount you may qualify for.
Speak with a friendly agent and get your quote in minutes!
Why is car insurance getting more expensive for everyone in 2026?
Even if nothing about your driving record or policy has changed, broader industry forces may still be pushing your premium higher.
How is inflation affecting car insurance rates?
Inflation has a direct impact on what insurers charge. As the cost to repair or replace vehicles rises, insurers pass those expenses on to policyholders.
The Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U) increased 2.4% in the last 12 months to an index of 319.799. The motor vehicle insurance index increased 7% year over year in June 2025, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Are labor shortages driving up insurance costs?
Yes. A shortage of skilled auto repair technicians — particularly those trained to work on luxury and high-end vehicles — is driving up repair costs. When mechanics charge more, insurers pay more per claim and pass those costs on to drivers.
Are car accidents getting more severe?
The rise of more severe car accidents and costlier insurance claims is forcing many insurers to raise premiums. Insurance companies must charge enough to remain financially stable when facing significantly higher claim payouts. Otherwise, they risk being unable to meet policyholder obligations.
How do rising medical costs affect car insurance?
Healthcare costs in the U.S. continue to climb. When a driver is injured in an accident, insurers must pay higher claim settlements to cover the full cost of medical treatment. Those increased costs get baked into the premiums drivers pay.
Is my insurance company raising rates just for me or for everyone?
Sometimes insurers raise premiums only for specific drivers. Other times, they raise rates across the board. Understanding which scenario applies to you can help you decide what to do next.
Every state has a department of insurance that regulates insurers operating within its borders. If an insurance company wants to raise premiums for all policyholders, the state insurance department must approve or deny the request based on what’s fair to consumers and current insurance laws.
Insurance companies must charge higher rates to remain profitable when rising claim costs, repair expenses and increased risk factors lead to higher payouts.
On the other hand, insurers raise premiums for individual drivers when that driver creates additional risk. This could mean several recent accidents, multiple moving violations or a DUI conviction.
If you’re unsure whether your premium increased because of personal or market factors, ask your insurance agent. Generally speaking, if you made changes to your policy, filed claims or received violations, your premium likely went up because of your risk profile.
How can I lower my car insurance if my rates keep going up?
If your premium keeps climbing, you have options. Here’s what you can do to bring costs down.
Shop around regularly for new quotes
Shopping around is one of the most effective ways to save on car insurance. Insurance companies use proprietary risk-assessment systems, so one insurer may charge you significantly less than another for the same coverage. Shop your coverage annually or anytime your premium goes up, and always compare the same coverage levels and deductibles.
Use our free car insurance calculator to compare rates quickly.
Raise your deductible
A higher deductible means a lower premium. Insurers charge less when you take on more financial responsibility per claim. If you can afford it, consider doubling your deductible — but always choose an amount you can comfortably pay out of pocket if you need to file a claim.
Adjust your coverage levels
Review your current coverage to make sure it’s appropriate for your situation. While you want to save money, your vehicles need to be adequately insured. State-required minimums are rarely enough to fully protect your car and other assets. Understanding the difference between liability-only and full coverage can help you find the right balance.
Ask your insurer about every available discount
Insurance companies offer a range of discounts that can meaningfully reduce your premium. Ask your agent about all available options, including bundling your home and auto insurance, paying your bill in full, multi-vehicle discounts, loyalty discounts, military discounts and defensive driving course credits.
Even small discounts add up. Signing up for electronic billing or paying annually instead of monthly can lower your rate. If your driving habits or vehicle have changed, let your insurer know — you may qualify for discounts you didn’t have before.
Try a usage-based or pay-per-mile program
Many insurers now offer usage-based insurance programs that can be cheaper than a traditional policy. Pay-per-mile insurance charges a flat monthly rate plus a small fee for each mile driven, so you only pay for the driving you actually do.
Telematics programs work similarly — you use a mobile app to track driving behaviors like speed and braking. Safe driving habits can earn you a lower premium. However, some telematics programs can increase your rate if the app detects risky driving patterns.
When should I switch car insurance companies?
Switching carriers can be a smart move if your rates keep rising. Consider it especially if you’ve recently experienced a life change such as moving, getting married or adding a teen driver to your policy. A recent accident, claim or new vehicle purchase is also a good reason to shop around.
Before switching, compare quotes from several insurers for the same types and amounts of coverage with matching deductibles. Look for companies that offer the coverage you need along with strong discounts, solid financial stability and positive customer reviews.
Our guides to the best car insurance companies and the cheapest car insurance can help you narrow your options.
When you do switch, avoid a gap in coverage. Ideally, your new policy’s effective date should overlap by a few days with your old policy’s end date so you’re continuously covered during the transition.
Will rates keep increasing? And, if so, why?
Car insurance rates are shaped by a mix of personal risk factors and industry-wide forces largely outside your control. While you can’t stop inflation from raising repair costs or prevent insurers from adjusting to higher claim payouts, you can take steps to manage what you pay.
Shop around regularly, ask about every available discount and make sure your coverage matches your needs. A little effort can go a long way toward keeping your premium in check.
Frequently Asked Questions: Why car insurance rates keep going up
Why is my car insurance going up even if I haven’t had an accident?
Premiums can rise due to market-wide factors like inflation, higher cost of repairs, more severe accidents/claims, or insurer-wide rate changes in your state.
Can my insurance company raise rates for everyone?
Yes — insurers often file rate increases with state regulators that apply broadly, meaning even safe drivers may see higher premiums.
Can my credit score affect my car insurance rate?
In most states, yes — insurers use credit-based scores to help predict risk, so changes in your credit score can influence your rate.
Does where I live affect my car insurance costs?
Absolutely. Rates are based partly on your ZIP code. If your area experiences more accidents, thefts, vandalism, or severe weather, insurers may raise premiums for all drivers in that region.
Will my car insurance go down if I switch companies?
It might. Shopping around and comparing quotes is one of the best ways to find lower rates, especially if your insurer raised premiums due to companywide adjustments.
How often should I shop for car insurance?
Experts recommend comparing quotes every 6 to 12 months or whenever you experience a life change — such as moving, buying a new car, or improving your credit.
Do insurance companies raise rates after one speeding ticket?
Yes. Even a single speeding ticket can increase your rate by 37% on average, depending on your insurer and state.
Will moving to a new ZIP code raise my insurance cost?
Absolutely — rates vary by ZIP code based on factors like traffic patterns, theft rates, weather risk and claims history in that area.
What’s the best way to lower ongoing rate increases?
Compare quotes annually, consider increasing your deductible if affordable, adjust coverage to your needs, ask about all discounts and explore usage-based programs.
Still have a question? Ask our experts
Get advice from an experienced insurance professional. Our experts will help you navigate your insurance questions with clarity and confidence.
Browse all FAQs
