Wrecked and uninsuredYou can legally drive without car insurance — but only with a significant cash outlay.

In Ohio, for example, you can get by with proof of financial responsibility. How do you get that? You can buy a $30,000 bond from an authorized surety company or deposit $30,000 with the state treasurer.

In South Carolina, you can pay a $550 fee to the state for a certificate of uninsured registration–every year. And be prepared to pay for any damage or injuries you cause.

You can drive without liability insurance in New Hampshire, too. If you happen to hit someone, you’ll need to post a “financial responsibility bond” on the spot to cover the damage. And you won’t be able to leave the state, because its neighbors require a policy.

Face it: While one in seven motorists hits the highway with no way to cover the costs of an accident, you do so at your own peril. Not only do you risk everything you own, but you could also face the consequences such as a fine, losing your vehicle, losing your license and serving jail time.

Why must you have car insurance?

“You have financial responsibility as a driver to carry insurance,” says Lynne McChristian, the Insurance Information Institute’s representative for Florida — a state with a high rate of uninsured motorists.

Not only does carrying the appropriate level of auto insurance protect you from possible civil and criminal penalties for not having it, but it also protects you if you damage someone else’s vehicle or injure them in a wreck. Otherwise, “the cost comes out of your pocket,” McChristian says.

Yet that doesn’t deter some motorists from getting behind the wheel when they don’t have insurance. This year’s study by the Insurance Research Council (IRC) found that about one in seven motorists nationwide doesn’t have coverage. However, it’s illegal not to have insurance or other proof of financial responsibility in every state but New Hampshire (where 89% of drivers carry a policy).

In some states, the uninsured driver rate is much higher, peaking in Mississippi, where an estimated 28 percent of motorists are uninsured, according to the IRC. In New Mexico, Tennessee, Oklahoma and Florida, about one-quarter of drivers have no insurance.

On the other end of the spectrum, about 5 percent of drivers in Massachusetts, Maine and New York don’t carry insurance.

The IRC has found that motorists are more likely to let their insurance lapse when unemployment rates are high. While some might see skipping auto insurance as a clever way to save cash, the risks can far outweigh any possible savings.

Driving without car insurance is risky

Driving without insurance can bring a multitude of perils. Alicia Charles-St. Juste, senior assistant vice president in sales and client services for Amica, says carrying the proper amount of coverage is “insurance for the unforeseen. My greatest fear is, what if I cause harm? I want to have peace of mind.”

You won’t have to worry about civil and criminal penalties if you purchase auto insurance. The IRC found they can run the spectrum, and enforcement can vary greatly. Driving without insurance, for example, can carry fines of less than $100 to more than $5,000, depending on the jurisdiction.

California has lowered its uninsured motorist rate using some strategies. One was establishing a computer system, so canceled policies are reported to the Department of Motor Vehicles. That prevents you from renewing your license or registration, says Pete Moraga, spokesman for the Insurance Information Network of California.

Law enforcement officials are also linked to the system, he says. Some motorists will make one insurance payment, then cancel but keep their insurance card, which they present if they’re in an accident. But the computer system shows officers whether or not the card is still valid.

An uninsured California motorist who is involved in an accident that’s not his fault also can’t sue the other driver for pain and suffering, Moraga says. That’s known as a “pay to play” provision.

Protect yourself from uninsured motorists

Because so many motorists are flouting the law, it’s essential to maintain uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage on your vehicle to protect yourself if you’re in a wreck and the other party can’t afford to pay.

“Many people just buy the minimum mandated by the state,” McChristian says. Such minimum amounts of liability coverage protect you from the damage you do to others, but often at levels that are not adequate to cover you if you cause serious damage to another driver.

“The minimum is not enough to protect you if you’re injured in an accident,” McChristian says. 

Some states make uninsured motorist coverage optional, but McChristian says, “it’s a really, really important coverage.”

Charles-St. Juste says maintaining such coverage is “almost like insurance against the other driver.”

Angela Preciado, director of the auto product management team at USAA, says some customers question the need for such coverage because they have good health insurance through their employer or the military. But drivers also need to consider their passengers, who might not have adequate health insurance coverage.

The best ways to cut car insurance costs

While it may be tempting to reject uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage to lower premiums, Preciado says many other options exist. Those include bundling your insurance policies with one insurer to get a discount. Or you may be eligible for a discount for being a safe driver, being a good student or being in the military.

She says you also may get a lower premium if you’ve cut back your driving. Low-mileage discounts can kick in anywhere from as low as 7,500 miles a year to as much as 12,000 or 15,000.

Another option is to raise your deductibles, which will lower your premiums. However, if you choose this option, you must have enough money tucked aside to cover your costs if you’re in a wreck, Preciado says.

She recommends reviewing your coverage every time you renew your policy. “As your life changes, your coverages should change as well,” she says.

That review should include phone calls or a few minutes online comparing auto insurance quotes. A CarInsurance.com analysis found the differences between carriers, especially for younger drivers, averaged as much as $1,102 a year.

If you can’t afford to pay your premiums, Moraga urges you to ride a bike, take a bus, or find a carpool rather than drive.

After all, bearing the burden of uninsured motorists forces premiums to rise.

“We all pay for other people’s crimes,” Moraga says.

Susan Ladika contributed to this story.

author image
Contributing Writer

Prachi is an insurance writer with a master’s degree in business administration. Through her writing, she hopes to help readers make smart and informed decisions about their finances. She loves to travel and write poetry.