Call Us Toll Free: 1-855-430-7753
Go To Top
Get Personalized Car Insurance Quotes
Currently Insured?

Car insurance loyalty rewards: Should I stay or should I go?


Woman near Exit signCar insurance companies care about keeping customers. To prevent you from straying, insurers offer an array of discounts, including ones that reward loyalty.

These loyalty discounts can be attractive. Nationwide, for one, says it may trim premiums by as much as 15 percent for someone who's carried one of its policies for at least five years. GEICO says clients could see a 30 percent drop in their rates, depending on how long they've been with the company. Many carriers (especially the big ones) offer similar enticements.

But should loyalty rewards be the main reason you stay with one company?

Industry professionals say no, pointing out that while these renewal discounts can be valuable, they should be considered next to your overall coverage needs -- and the price you pay for them -- and other available discounts. Find the average car insurance rates in your city or town to find out what you can expect to pay.

"A loyalty discount for staying with your insurance company is nice, but it is just a discount -- you shouldn't stay with a car insurance company just because of it," says Penny Gusner, consumer analyst for Insure.com. "If you've received bad customer service or believe you're paying too much, go out there and shop around for a new provider. By comparison shopping you may find cheaper rates even without receiving a loyalty discount."

A recent car insurance shopping study by the Texas Office of Public Insurance Counsel supports the idea that shopping for a new policy can lead to savings. A consumer who has stuck with the same car insurer for eight years could reduce the premium by 19 percent, on average, by switching, according to the report.

Michael Barry, the vice president of media relations for the Insurance Information Institute, says the III is neutral on loyalty rewards and most other insurer discounts. Insurance is a very competitive business, he says, and firms use these provisions to keep policyholders while appealing to new ones.

Consumers should also examine policy details when shopping. Progressive, for instance, also includes service perks in its loyalty rewards program.

The benefits, frequently pushed in TV commercials featuring the ubiquitous "Flo" singing a tortured version of "I'll Stand by You," provide "accident forgiveness" (where rates don't rise after most crashes) for those holding a policy for at least five years, according to Progressive.

Some insurers have comparable incentives; ask companies for details.

Gusner notes that you can also get a transfer discount (usually 5 to 10 percent) when switching carriers. Unlike a loyalty discount, this is usually offered only once, at the time of buying a policy. But loyalty discounts may kick in if you continue with the carrier.

Price optimization: Are insurers charging you more for staying loyal?

If you do decide to stay with your current insurer, you should be aware of a practice called "price optimization." Insurers sometimes use this little-known technique to penalize loyal auto insurance policyholders by charging them higher rates because the insurer believes they are unlikely to shop around for a better price. Some insurers try to predict who is less likely to switch companies, by testing incremental price increases, and then charge those customers more in order to squeeze out higher profits.

The practice is under review by some state insurance regulators, thanks to a report by the Consumer Federation of America (CFA). Insurance regulators in Florida have banned price optimization, while regulators in California and Ohio have issued warnings against it. New York and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners are investigating the tactic. Vermont Insurance Commissioner Susan Donegan recently directed all insurance companies to disclose any use of price optimization and highlighted the state's prohibition on any use of pricing techniques unrelated to risk.

Insurers, such as Allstate, have denied that they do this and maintain that their rates are based on risk factors and are legal and actuarially sound.

Going beyond loyalty rewards to save

Renewal rewards are just one of the car insurance discounts out there. There are several more -- from those tied to safety features to bundling vehicle insurance with homeowners coverage. Here's a rundown of what's offered by most companies:

  • Safe driver: A clean driving record for a certain number of years -- typically three -- may snag a discount.
  • Good student: Full-time students with at least a "B" average usually qualify.
  • Driving classes: Young and older drivers who pass accredited courses can qualify. Many insurers accept online classes as well as those in the classroom.
  • Low mileage: A discount is usually provided for those who drive less than 10,000 miles a year. The threshold may vary with insurers.
  • Anti-theft: You'll probably get a rate break if your vehicle has anti-theft or vehicle recovery devices.
  • Safety features: Air bags and antilock brakes are among the safety features that will probably get you a discount.
  • Multi-car: Lower premiums typically come if you have more than one vehicle on the policy.

Be aware that some insurers limit the amount of discounts you get for some coverages - your reduction total may be capped at a certain percentage, even if you qualify for all the discounts. Again, ask your insurer; they should tell you if discounts are capped.

A little research makes a lot of sense

Gusner is quick to point out that consumers should go beyond loyalty rewards and other discounts when buying insurance. "Discounts are one thing to look at but you also need to look at customer service, consumer reviews, the financial stability of the company -- and of course price," she advises.

Here are a few steps to help you find the right insurer:

  • What does your state department of insurance say? Every state has a department that regulates insurers and is designed to protect consumers. Most of these departments publish "consumer complaint ratios" on their websites, which usually show how many complaints an insurer receives per 1,000 coverage claims. Compare ratios from one company to the next. If your state department doesn't have "consumer complaint ratios," then check other nearby states that do.
  • Is the company financially sound? Financial strength ratings of companies are provided by Standard & Poor's and A.M. Best, with both grading an insurer's ability to pay out claims. Only consider companies with at least a B+ rating at A.M. Best and don't go below a BBB for Standard & Poor's. An insurer's website may offer this information. Or do a search at the Standard & Poor's and A.M. Best sites.
  • Study satisfaction ratings. Consumer Reports, J.D. Power and other researchers frequently rate insurers. Consider companies that receive high marks. Also, Insure.com publishes customer satisfaction rankings that may be helpful.

Leave a Comment
Ask a Question
Tell us your thoughts
Leave a Comment

1 Responses to "Car insurance loyalty rewards: Should I stay or should I go?"
  1. Nancy

    We have been with Progressive almost 2 years. Our rate goes up every 6 months. We quit past insurance companies because of rate increases when we've never had an accident that's been our fault or ticket and have always paid our bill on time. Not sure who to go with anymore.

Disclaimer: Answers and comments provided are for information purposes. They are not intended to substitute informed professional advice. These responses should not be interpreted as a recommendation to buy or sell any insurance product, or to provide financial or legal advice. Please refer to your insurance policy for specific coverage and exclusion information. Please read our Terms of Service.

Ask Your Question Now


Penny will do whatever research it takes to find your answer ASAP.